Album Review: U2 - Songs of Surrender
We have a new U2 album! Well...kind of. Songs of Surrender, the first release from the band in over five years, is finally here, and it's not exactly the project any of us wanted or expected. Containing 40 re-recorded songs, it's the band's attempt at doing their own unplugged/reinterpreted project. To be fair, everyone from Moby to The Cranberries have done an album similar to this, so it's not fair to ding U2 for indulging themselves in this fashion. At the same time, U2 fans have been starving for new material and getting this after so long leaves the listener feeling unsatisfied.
Loosely tied into Bono's recent memoir, these 40 songs are largely a lockdown project from Bono and The Edge. Most of the tunes are recorded acoustically and contain minimal overdubs or instrumentation. Normally seeing U2 work in this fashion would be thrilling, expect that most of these songs end up sounding the same. This might not be so bad if limited to 10-15 tracks, but at 40 it all becomes a blur of acoustic guitars, piano, and Bono's hit-or-miss vocals. The physical release is divided into four discs with 10 song each, which is how I recommend approaching this project. Taking it all in at once is just too much, but in short bursts it can be fairly pleasant if you're in the right mood.
There are some tracks that benefit from this treatment. The horns on "Red Hill Mining Town" are a nice touch, as is the funky arrangement of "Get Out of Your Own Way", which felt lyrically and musically undercooked on Songs of Experience. Here it becomes a bit more playful and balances out its counterpart somewhat competently. Other songs like "11 O'Clock Tick Tock", "The Fly", and "Two Hearts Beat as One" manage to exude a bit of energy, though they're unfortunately the exception. Having Edge take lead vocals on a few tracks is nice, especially on "Stories for Boys".
That being said, many of these tracks begin to feel like a dirge; they're slow, quiet, and suffer from having similar arrangements. This was a chance for the band to really rediscover and rearrange these tunes--instead they just feel like b-sides or demos. Far too often there's just not enough going on to keep you fully invested, and the fact that Adam and Larry feel largely absent makes it even more bizarre. This really comes off as Bono and Edge just playing together, thus removing the sense of this being a genuine U2 release.
In the end there isn't much to be said for Songs of Surrender. It's hard to tell if this was a passion project or something thrown together because the group is out of ideas. I have enjoyed it more than I expected, though that's likely due to going in with bottom of the barrel expectations. It's fine background music, and there are moments when some of these songs can grab you, but those highs are few and far between. After waiting so long I was really hoping for more.
Let's just pray that we don't have to wait another half-decade to see what's next. Only the hardcore and extremely curious need apply this time around.

Comments
Post a Comment