Underrated Record Club: Manic Street Preachers - Lifeblood
Ranking the records of Manic Street Preachers is no easy task. Each one is filled with great songs and follows its own unique trajectory. They've managed to constantly reinvent themselves without veering too far from the energy and melodies that have made them so beloved. Everything Must Go remains my favorite, a sprawling and beautiful work that found the group working through grief and uncertainty with big, colorful arrangements. It remains a critically-accliamed work and has lost none of its potency. But what would my rankings look like after that? I have to confess: Lifeblood would take second place.
I'm well aware that most fans will baulk at that statement. After all, how could other beloved works like The Holy Bible, Send Away the Tigers, or This Is My Truth Tell Me Yours not be next? To be fair, all three of those albums round out my top five, so they sit near the top of the pile. I genuinely believe the Manics have never made a bad album---some are just a little better than others. Heck, there are even days where Lifeblood vies for the top position. My love for it runs deep, so permit me a few minutes to gush about this overlooked masterpiece.
The opener "1985" is brilliant. Swirling synths mixed with some nice guitar work kick everything into high gear. Frontman James Dean Bradfield is always in command, with this album featuring some of his best and most mature vocal work. The Manics formed in 1986, so setting the song a year earlier is interesting and helps to make it more personal to the listener. This was the year of my birth, so perhaps I feel more attachment to the track than those born before or after. The tone for the record has been set: it's poppier, denser, and finds the group expanding their sound yet again.
Lead single "The Love of Richard Nixon" is interesting. It might get my vote for weakest song on the album, though that's due more to the strength of the material around it than the actual song itself. Drummer Sea Moore fixes the groove with a danceable beat that instantly grabs your attention. The band had played with something similar on "Miss Europa Disco Dancer" on their previous LP, but this is far more realized and confident. The high-pitched synth parts compliment the song nicely, making it one of the most unique songs from the band up to that point.
"Empty Souls" bursts out of the gate with a driving beat and icy piano. The piano and keyboard accompaniments on this record are integral to its sound, giving it a chilly tone that never becomes overbearing or distracting. Considering this was the era when piano-driven groups like Coldplay and Keane were emerging, it seemed to be a bit of a trend at the time. Thankfully this has aged wonderfully and continues to thrill nearly 20 years later. The lyrics seem to be a response to September 11, though only one line references the event directly. I also like Bradfield's brief, fuzzy solo. I'm a sucker for little things like that.
"A Song for Departure" comes next, beginning with gentle piano and some nice bass work from Nicky Wire. It has a nice groove that recalls indie and pop bands. I can imagine a number of fans were turned off by this. After all, Manic Street Preachers is a rock band first and foremost; they do it incredibly well but have always shown a desire to try new things. For my money it pays off big time, both on "A Song for Departure" and throughout all of Lifeblood.
Wire has referred to the album "elegiac pop", an apt description that's proven even more true on "I Live to Fall Asleep". A firm but driving pop song, it describes the beauty of sleep and then impact that dreams can have on that cycle. It feels a bit mournful without ever becoming sad or downtrodden.
What follows next is my favorite MSP song. "To Repel Ghosts" is simply thrilling, with its U2-esque guitar and vocals set against a relentless beat and towering keyboards. Wire's bass holds it all together and the chorus is classic Manics: big, catchy, and ready for any stadium in the world. It's genius and definitely the one track I would readily recommend to anyone looking to check out the album.
The beautiful keyboards of "Emily", matched with more of Wire's outstanding bass work, open side two with a bang. Written about feminist and suffrage leader Emily Pankhurst, it's a stunning piece of work with a chorus that gives me chills every time. It's undeniably a Manics song but delivered with a very template.
"Glasnost" displays Bradfield's intricate guitar and Moore's drumming is understated but powerful at the same time. Once again we're treated a great chorus and more of the album's layered production. I absolutely love it and "Glasnost" is a wonderful example of just how well the band was able to balance all of these elements.
The big hero of "Always/Never" is Nicky Wire. His funky bass permeates the entire track, propelling it forward along with some pretty and engaging keyboards. It's a far cry from the post-punk screeches of the band's early work, yet that's why I love it so much. This is the Manics doing what all great artists seek to do: pushing themselves and trying something fresh.
The brooding "Solitude Sometimes Is" remains another favorite. Bradfield's voice really excels and it's clear just how much he's matured as a vocalist. Wire and Moore hold everything down with a steady mid-tempo groove that gives James plenty of room to maneuver his voice and guitar. I can't describe how exciting it is to hear the band tackle something like this and they pull it off without a hitch.
Perhaps the most experimental song on the album, "Fragments" is gentle and sounds very tender. It's hard to put into words, but I can say that I've come to treasure this song. It's soothing, pensive, sad, hopeful, and thoughtful all at the same time. It fits any mood and only gets better with repeated listens. It's an underrated gem on an album already full of them.
The record closes with "Cardiff Afterlife". Beginning with bouncing drums and harmonica, it's another left-turn that works far better than you would expect. It seems pretty obvious to me that this is about former bandmate Richey Edwards, whose disappearance seems to haunt this album. Much of the record seems to explore grief, death, and memory, something we are all affected by at one point or another. As Wire once said in an interview: "Lifeblood doesn't seek to exorcise Edwards' ghost, though, just admits that there are no answers."
And that's ultimately why I believe the album is so powerful. Things happen that we can't explain, we lose people we love, and sometimes we don't get an answer this side of eternity. Lifeblood is beautiful and a testament to just how diverse Manic Street Preachers can be. I know a lot of fans hate it, and even the band themselves have pretty much dismissed it, but I'm proud to be one of the few that sees the value in what they did with this particular release. It's the kind of album that can only come from a place of maturity.
Maybe this one is my favorite.


Comments
Post a Comment