Album Review: Weezer (Black Album)
I apologize for this review being so late, but sometimes life gets busy and you need a while to really decide how you feel about a particular record. My mental jury has reached their conclusion...
Oh Weezer. For a couple years it looked like they were back on track and had learned from the mistakes in their past. Everything Will Be Alright in the End and The White Album restored many fans' faith in the band and gave us hope that Weezer was returning to what they do best. Then Pacific Daydream was dropped on us and, while not a terrible record, it failed to light the fanbase up or to instill a sense of excitement for what was coming next. I was concerned but still held out hope that The Black Album would blow us all away. Instead it comes off more like Pacific Daydream Part II, with shades of an interesting album showing through the cracks.
This record isn't a rock album like many were expecting, at least not in the traditional sense. The crunchy guitars, crashing drums, and wall of sound that made so many other Weezer albums endearing are virtually nonexistent. Instead they have been replaced with sterile production and clean guitars that take any kind of edge out of these tunes. Songs like "Living in L.A.", "The Prince Who Wanted Everything" and "I'm Just Being Honest" have solid melodies that never get off the ground because they're begging for a more organic sound. "High as a Kite" is the lone exception, a great ballad that makes use of the production and feels authentic. It's hard to know what to make of songs like "California Snow" and "Byzantine" due to the sheer cascade of loops, synths, beats, and guitars tossed in. The songs are serviceable but fail to leave any lasting impact.
"Can't Knock the Hustle" gets points for bringing a funky bass line and some attitude, yet feels too silly and undercooked to be anything more than a curiosity. "Zombie Bastards" and "Piece of Cake" suffer a similar fate, though the former does at least stick in your head long after it's over. "Too Many Thoughts in My Head" throws a cacophony of sound at the listener, sucking you into the song and leaving you a bit disoriented. Again, the pristine production takes away from the song instead of adding to it; a rougher mix would have made this a certified hit. The album reeks of being remixed and reworked so many times that much of the soul (presuming it was there to begin with) has long since been filtered out.
There's fun to be had with The Black Album, and I've listened to it more times than I can count. Even a mediocre Weezer album has some redeeming value (except Raditude, but I think that goes without saying). The biggest issue is that this is the second album in a row that's gone for a glossy, poppy style and it doesn't suit this band at all. The songs themselves have potential but are held back by overproduction and a lack of focus. I appreciate the band trying new things, but when they're not executed well it taints the entire project. This could have been a monster rock album and instead comes off as another "fine" release that doesn't move the band forward and instead sets them back yet again. There's a good album buried in here. I just wish Rivers had let it shine through.
I'll continue to listen and enjoy those brief moments when the album shines. I love Weezer but they can do so much better. Don't get mad at me...I'm just being honest.


Comments
Post a Comment