Underrated Record Club: No Line on the Horizon
Ten years ago it was both a strange and exhilarating time. I had just graduated from college, feeling relief at finally being done with school while also questioning the wisdom of graduating right in the middle of a massive recession. They can teach you a lot at school, but sadly economics is becoming a lost art. In the midst of trying to find some kind of job to support myself there was one ray of light that kept me going---U2 were scheduled to finally release No Line on the Horizon. After months of delays and even years of vague news it looked like things were falling into place, ending the grueling four-and-a-half year wait that fans had learned to endure by this stage in the band's career. Hype was ramping up and I was swept right up in the middle of it.
Seeing as how the record is coming up on its 10th anniversary (making me feel extremely old in the process) it seems like as good a time as any to revisit this record and encourage others to jump on board. Let's go track by track and look for that horizon line, even though it's clearly visible on the beautiful yet vague cover art!
NO LINE ON THE HORIZON
Right off the bat this album explodes in vibrancy and color. I love Edge's fuzzy guitar, which would not have sounded out of place back on Achtung Baby. Immediately we're thrust into new territory as layers of percussion, synths, and guitars wash over us. It's a rock song and yet so much denser than what the band had delivered on their last couple of releases. While some may complain that Bono does more shouting than actual singing on this one, I don't find it to be distracting. It lends an urgency to the performance that keeps the song driving along. It's a terrific way to start the album and it felt like a natural progression for the band at that stage in their career.
MAGNIFICENT
A bit more "standard U2" with just a dose of atmosphere to keep it from sounding too familiar. I love the build-up at the beginning and Bono's lyrics are particularly poignant, treading that find line between the spiritual and the physical. It takes the band's trademark sound and updates it just enough to feel like a new take on an old friend.
MOMENT OF SURRENDER
This is far and away one of the finest songs the band has penned in the last 20 years. It's seven minutes of pure beauty, lending a sparse arrangement that gives the song plenty of breathing room. It's relaxed yet frantic, modern yet classic, sad yet hopeful. Apparently most of this song was recorded in a single take, which might explain why it feels so natural and never looses its momentum. I loved it a decade ago and I still love it now. Thankfully most fans and critics seem to share that sentiment.
UNKNOWN CALLER
Let's start by stating the obvious: some of the lyrics are pretty goofy. "Force quit and move to trash!" Thanks Bono, but us Mac folks have known that for quite some time. Once you get around some of the clunky metaphors the song quickly takes on a life of its own. It's a sequel to "Moment of Surrender", where the desperate narrator receives a mysterious text message that appears to be from God. The concept might cause some to roll their eyes but I rather like this approach. Throughout much of the album Bono experiments by writing from the perspective of others and telling stories that aren't typically his own. It's also quite cool getting a direct sequel to the previous track, something that we never really got before on any previous U2 album. The music itself is gorgeous and I can't say enough great things about the last minute of this song. Edge wins again.
I'LL GO CRAZY IF I DON'T GO CRAZY TONIGHT
Ah yes, the tried and true U2 tradition of ridiculously long song titles still remains. Here it manifests itself as something lighter and more radio-friendly. This begins what some refer to as the "unholy trinity" of the record, a three-song stint where the band trades the narrative and experimental tone of the record for a last-ditch effort to recreate the success of "Beautiful Day" and "Vertigo." Let me be upfront: I don't actually hate these songs. They're serviceable and fun enough for what they are. However, they don't belong on the album and they feel woefully disconnected from everything that comes before and after. This track is fine for a summertime pop tune but that's about it. Bono tries to hit some notes that are painfully out of his range and rest of the band is just kind of along for the ride. It's serviceable but also the first song on the album that doesn't feel like it's truly reaching for greatness.
GET ON YOUR BOOTS
This was our first taste of the album---and many chose not to order the rest of the meal. Again, this song is fun when taken for the silliness that it is (and it was excellent when played live) but once again it totally derails the sound and themes of the record. The lyrics don't make much sense and the melody has been ripped from several better songs. It doesn't belong on the album and releasing it as the lead single was absolutely bonkers. Get on your thinking caps, lads!
STAND UP COMEDY
I dig the Led Zeppelin riff that Edge contributes, and Larry has some nice drum moments, but it's another song that should have be relegated to a B-side or later release. Out of the middle three this might be my favorite, but it still doesn't fit, and it's a travesty to put a rocker on the album and then not even play it live. I believe that would have helped redeem this track in the eyes of many.
FEZ-BEING BORN
Now we're talking. This is far and away my favorite track on the album. It's gorgeous, bold, touching, and bursting with creativity. The interplay of guitar and piano near the end is sheer heaven. Every member of the band gets a chance to shine and it makes me wish more of the album could have sounded like this. This is my favorite side of U2--big, driving, and atmospheric.
WHITE AS SNOW
This tender ballad borrows liberally from "O Come, O Come, Emmanuel." It takes that melody and builds a sweet story about a solider's final thoughts before he dies. I feel this one often gets overlooked in the larger U2 discography and that's a shame. It's a tune that offers more than it might reveal on first listen.
BREATHE
"I wasn't gonna buy just anyone's cockatoo!" Um, okay? Bono's lyrics may once again be "mixed", to put it mildly, but the song itself is actually quite good. Edge really gets to light it up with a great solo while Larry and Adam give the bottom end a massive boost. It's a rock song that at least feels like it fits into the flow of the album. Bono's rapid fire delivery may be an acquired taste for some, but it's something I have always believed worked well. In short: I dig it.
CEDARS OF LEBANON
The album's pensive closer is U2 at their most subtle and experimental. It's a dark and understated finale that ranks as one of their best. It really has to be heard to be understood and fully appreciated.
No Line on the Horizon is an interesting beast. It's definitely not as mainstream as what came before and it failed to fully catch on with the general public. Sadly the band has apparently tossed it into the dust bin along with Pop, writing it off as another failure that didn't perform the way they expected. I believe part of that is due to the album's uneven nature, especially in the middle. When you hear outtakes like "Soon", "Winter", and "North Star", it's baffling why these tracks were left off the album in favor of the middle three. They started out making an experimental album and ultimately sacrificed some of that vision for what they believed would be hit singles. Had they stuck with their initial ideas I feel the album would be looked back on much more fondly.
That being said, I still love this record. It makes me feel like I'm on a boat in the middle of the ocean, staring at the calm water trailing off in every direction. In that regard the album cover, production, and lyrics really come together. If you can get around the band's self-sabotage in some areas then this is an underrated gem that deserves a second chance. The vinyl reissue is coming out next month and hopefully that will give everyone a reason to take a second listen. This LP deserves it.



Comments
Post a Comment