Album Review: The Decemberists - I'll Be Your Girl



It's hard not to feel a sense of disappointment with The Decemberists' latest release. 2015's What a Terrible World, What a Beautiful World may have been messy but it at least felt like the band was trying to branch out in ways that made sense. Fast forward to I'll Be Your Girl and the result, while more focused, is the least impressive moment in their discography so far.

The album opens promisingly with "Once in My Life", with the band in full force and Colin Meloy delivering exactly what you expect from a seasoned veteran. "Cutting Stone" is a bit more downbeat but manages to stay the course due to some subtle synth effects. This is a recurring theme throughout the album, with the group trying to channel New Order and Roxy Music by incorporating more synths and glossy production into their trademark sound. Unfortunately this shift produces more misses than hits, resulting in a group so desperate to get out of their traditional style that the record suffers because of it. "Severed" isn't too shabby, though it doesn't beam with the confidence that the driving back beat and synths would imply. Songs like "Tripping Along" and "We All Die Young" are so pedestrian and vapid that it's hard to believe they could come from the same band who gave us so much more just a few years ago. "Everything Is Awful" is the kind of whiny and repetitive track that sounds too amateurish for a band of this caliber, while "Sucker's Prayer" fares better, sounding like a lost Counting Crows song and that's a good thing. "We All Die Young" is comprised of a chorus of children singing and it's...bad. Really bad.

The record's best moments work on tracks like "Starwatcher" and the album's title track, which strip things down to the bare essentials and are all the better for it. One track that seems to be getting universal praise is "Rusalka, Rulsalka/Wild Rushes", and with good reason. It's the album's standout track, a throwback to the epic literary tales that endeared so many of us to the band in the first place.

I will tip my hat to the group for trying something different; it's natural for artists to want to do that. However, simply changing the formula isn't enough to automatically make it pay off. The Decemerbists are at a junction where they need to decide what they want to be and then commit to it completely. At this point I'll Be Your Girl is the sound of a band tired of their sound and yet unable to find another mold that fits them. Let's hope they find their footing next time.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Space Fact of the Week

10 Best Lyrics from Trouble Will Find Me

Underrated Record Club: Death Cab for Cutie - Codes and Keys