Album Review: The Shins - Heartworms


James Mercer is an artist who always seems to turn out great music. Whether that's through The Shins, Broken Bells, or something else entirely, he always manages to wrap clever lyrics around a bubbling melody. Add to that his feather light vocals and you have a formula that has severed him well over the last 15 years. Heartworms, his first Shins project in nearly five years, should be a sweet homecoming but ultimately feels like a disjointed foray into various sights and sounds without a strong foundation to hold them all together.

There are some real bright spots here, from the brooding “So Now What” to the gentile autobiography of “Mildenhall”. “Cherry Hearts” and “Dead Alive” also manage to combine slick studio production with the classic Shins sound we’ve come to know and love. These moments show that Mercer can still create an engrossing atmosphere and formidable pop song, as the album’s title track will attest to. These might not rank as instant classics but they do give me so reason to return to the album.

The problem resides with these rest of the LP. “Name for You”, “Painting a Hole” and “Fantasy Island” all suffer from layered production without a strong hook to pull you in. “Rubber Ballz” and “Half a Million” both float by without much to cling to in terms of melody or lyrical finesse. Close “The Fear” works a bit better but never quite builds into anything truly incredible. The biggest gripe I can find with Heartworms is that is simply doesn’t stick with you. Even after numerous spins I have trouble humming many of these melodies or recalling a lyric that struck me as poignant or clever. It’s the first time when a Shins album just feels okay---certainly not bad but hardly the go-to material that their previous records were. Too often the album feels forced and unfocused, as if Mercer had too many ideas and had to hammer something out of them. The few solid tracks on this release aren’t enough to make up for the rest, which dissolve from your memory almost as soon as they end.



To call Heartworms a bad album would be doing it a disservice. There are several good songs and a couple decent ones that show glimmers of the band’s past brilliance. Unfortunately I can’t call it a great album either. It straddles the line and too often feels like something that Mercer forced himself to put out, rather than something that came naturally. This record desperately needed something like “Know Your Onion!”, “Simple Song” or “Phantom Limb”, a catchy and irresistible pop song to pull you in and keep you invested. It’s just not here and the record as a whole suffers from too many ideas without solid execution. Only diehard fans need apply this time around.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Space Fact of the Week

10 Best Lyrics from Trouble Will Find Me

Underrated Record Club: Death Cab for Cutie - Codes and Keys