Album Review: Bloc Party - Hymns
I realize that this review is late (about nine months late, to be exact) but I might as well get this out there, especially because I sense this will be my biggest musical disappointment of 2016. What happened to these guys?
I love Bloc Party and have for a number of years. Like many, I was captivated by Silent Alarm and thoroughly enjoyed the following albums as the band continued to experiment and grow. Some were better than others but the spark that made the band so endearing was still there, although by Four I could tell that something was off. There were cracks in the hull and the band sounded distant and forced, lacking some of the passion and raw energy that had propelled them to greatness in the first place. Hearing later that their unequaled rhythm section had departed had me severely worried. It turns out I had reason to be.
Hymns is so lackluster and dull that I have trouble recalling more than a couple of tracks. Even after numerous listens there is nothing to excite me, nothing to tap my foot to and certainly nothing that I can air-drum too (be honest, you do it too). The entire record feels like a Kele solo project, with the band hardly showing up at all. Dull, uneventful drums, forgettable bass lines and muted guitar are all you get. Remember when Bloc Party did things like that? It's because they never did, at least not to the extremes presented here. The tasteful ballads of previous tunes like "Signs" and "Blue Light" are long gone; in the their place we get songs like "Fortress" and "Only He Can Heal Me", neither of which is likely to make your essential Bloc Party playlist. "The Love Within" is a decent opener and I like it only because it's one of the rare moments on Hymns where something actually happens. It's a fairly weak track but on this album it shines simply because it brings a brief moment of momentum to a record that flatlines soon after. "Into the Earth" and "The Good News" try to bring a bit of light back but they're both too repetitive and dreary to add much weight. Even the bonus tracks are forgettable, something I couldn't say for Intimacy and A Weekend in the City. Actual hymns are bombastic, sweeping, emotional and uplifting. For an album that bears that title there's certainly nothing of the sort here. It's baffling beyond measure.
The only saving grace is that Hymns isn't a complete loss. It's produced well, has a couple decent tracks and has some fine lyrical moments. It's a great background record or something that can help you relax as you fall asleep...but is that really what we want from Bloc Party? I have no qualms with a band trying new things---in fact, I encourage it---but it needs to be done with some care and passion, both of which are lacking here. I've been a big fan for many years and I sincerely hope that their next endeavor is something fresh. I hope they can find that passion again and use all members, both old and new, to the full extent of their abilities. This band can do so much better. The big question is: do they want to?


Comments
Post a Comment