Album Review: Switchfoot - Where the Light Shines Through


I’ve been a Switchfoot fan ever since New Way to Be Human was released back in 1999. I can still remember the days of wearing a Switchfoot t-shirt to school and having hardly anyone recognize them. My wife even had a friend who made a bet that the band would never make it big because “they were terrible”. She’s still waiting on that $20 payment. Needless to say, I’ve believed in this band for a long time and after 17 years I continue to do so, though my excitement has worn off a bit over the past few years. Where the Light Shines Through has a lot going for it, yet it also suffers some of the same problems that have plagued the group’s previous records, leaving it in a difficult spot and leaving me with conflicted feelings.

The album starts off on a very positive note. “Holy Water” is a solid rocker, the kind of engaging anthem that the band has become known for and it grabs your attention immediately. Unfortunately “Float” really kills the momentum and takes the album into a left turn that feels unnatural. The song has grown on me over time but within the context of the album it feels forced; it should have been moved in the running order or saved for another project. Thankfully the album’s title track and “I Won’t Let You Go” keep things moving, with the latter being one of the album’s best cuts. I have to give particular attention to “If the House Burns Down Tonight”, both lyrically and musically. It manages to be both catchy and intriguing, driving at a restless pace while looking at the differences between possessions and relationships. “The Day That I Found God” is equally beautiful. The first half of this album fares quite well and offers us a number of wonderful moments.

The second half feels patchier. “Bull in a China Shop” and “Healer of Souls” both fail to leave much of an impression even after numerous listens. “Shake This Feeling” and “Live It Well” feel a bit generic but work well enough for what they are. “Looking for America” is the weakest cut on this LP, a fact that the normally talented Lecrae can’t save. It feels like what it is: a couple of artists complaining about America without offering any real solutions beyond surface level catchphrases. Sure, America is in trouble, but couldn’t the band at least turn that into something more inspiring than the typical “feel guilty because of the nation’s past” rhetoric that’s been far too prevalent over the past few years? I used to think Switchfoot was above that sort of thing but here they sound woefully out of their depth. Thankfully “Hope Is the Anthem” ends the album with a bang and continues the band’s tradition of exhilarating closers.


Where the Light Shines Through is a bit inconsistent but musically it feels lively and diverse, with enough variety that even the pickiest of listeners should walk away satisfied. What holds the album back (at least for me) is the lyrics, which have been a problem for several records now. Jon Foreman knows how to write deep and convicting lyrics, as evidenced by tunes like “The Economy of Mercy”, “The Shadow Proves the Sunshine” and “Company Car.” That was one of the elements that drew me to the band initially and there are times when I still catch glimpses of it. The problem is that Jon rests on the same topics over and over again. Here are some examples:

* Love
* Hope
* Rising up
* Inner struggle
* Finding meaning
* The ocean
* Troubled youth
* Materialism
* Darkness
* Fighting

Normally those topics are fine and even inspiring but by now I feel Jon has exhausted these topics. Too often he now treads a line of generic catchphrases and muddy solutions, neither singing boldly about his faith nor denying the existence of God. It feels watered-down and vague, something that I wouldn’t have expected from the band 15 years ago. I yearn for the songs were Jon thinks outside the box and writes about something unexpected and thought-provoking. Love and hope are wonderful things but there are ways to approach these issues from new and inventive angles. Tracks like “If the House Burns Down Tonight” prove they can still do it and it would be great to see more like it.


I apologize for a longer than normal review but I think Switchfoot is one of the best and most talented bands we’ve had in the past 20 years. It’s out of love and care that I point out when the band isn’t working because I want them to be the best they can be. Where the Light Shines Through is excellent in many respects---but the cliché lyrics and uneven pacing hold it back from being truly great. My wife and I will be seeing them in September and it will no doubt be a marvelous experience. I’d just like to see them push their lyrics and solutions as far as the music allows.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Space Fact of the Week

10 Best Lyrics from Trouble Will Find Me

Underrated Record Club: Death Cab for Cutie - Codes and Keys