Underrated Record Club: St. Anger


St. Anger is a fascinating mess. It's brutal, it's terribly produced and it's real. Those conflicting thoughts plague this album and it's undoubtably the most polarizing album in Metallica's discography. While I'll readily admit that it's their weakest album, it does have some positive aspects that save it from being a total waste. I'm not a big metal fan but I do enjoy Metallica's music and their willingness to try new things, even if those chances don't always pay off.

If nothing else, this album is upfront and feels emotionally authentic. St. Anger is the sound of pure frustration, surely born out of James Hetfield's stint in rehab and tensions inside the band. Listening to him work out his struggles and personal demons is both frightening and incredible, giving this record a feel unlike any other they've made before or since. The record is a snapshot in time of a band on the verge of imploding, a fact that's further enforced by the documentary Some Kind of Monster. The fact that Metallica is still around is somewhat of a miracle after going through all of those internal struggles. While Hetfield's lyrics are definitely some of the weakest he's ever penned, they're also some of his most personal and interesting. He's not hiding anything here and I suspect at this point he couldn't even if he wanted to. The production is famously awful but the playing is quite good, at least when you can hear the individual parts. Lars in particular has some great moments; it's just a shame he decided to leave the snares off his actual snare and opted for a hollow sound. For all the fans who complained that Load and Reload were too polished and mainstream...they got the opposite here.

I don't mind the lack of solos but the songs themselves needed to be trimmed down as a result. Tracks like "Invisible Kid", "Some Kind of Monster" and "St. Anger" have potential but drag on about three minutes longer than necessary, leading to songs that cause you to tune out due to monotony. Even the longer songs on albums like ...And Justice for All had interesting instrumentals and time changes to keep them fresh. This record desperately needed more of that and some tracks ("My World", "Shoot Me Again" and "All Within My Hands") don't really work, though I'm sure a decent tune is buried in there somewhere. The real saving grace of this release is "The Unnamed Feeling", which even critics will usually admit to liking. It's here where the rough production and raw lyrics come together to create something special. If you took the record's 75 minute running time and chopped it down to about 45-60 minutes then the entire record would feel much more immediate and less like a marathon.




The question I have to ask myself is this: does St. Anger work? Can I really defend it and called it underrated? The answer is more elusive. The production is lacking in just about every area and vocally, as well as lyrically, James is really struggling on a lot of these tunes. For all the problems this album has, I kind of like for what it is. I have to be in a very specific mood to listen to it but there are times when St. Anger works as a weird experiment. I understand why a lot of fans hate it, and their complaints are very valid, yet there's just enough here that does work to make it worth an occasional spin. The band bounced back with Death Magnetic, so they still have what it takes. This just seems like something they had to get out of their system in order to find themselves again.

St. Anger is a mess...but one that I'm okay with.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Space Fact of the Week

10 Best Lyrics from Trouble Will Find Me

Underrated Record Club: Death Cab for Cutie - Codes and Keys