Second Listens: Working on a Dream (2009)



Call me strange but I'm one of those weirdos who tends to like the records that others hate. My Underrated Record Club columns make that pretty clear and there are a lot of hated albums that I'll defend and admit to enjoying. Working on a Dream has been maligned by enough fans and critics to the point where it's pretty much the consummate "this was his really bad one" record. Even Bruce's weaker albums (Human Touch, The Ghost of Tom Joad) have a few knockouts that keep me coming back. Often Bruce is at least able to maintain a good average in terms of songs and solid recordings so this should have been at least decent. Upon first listen I found it embarrassing and lifeless. After giving it additional time and more listens the question remains: is Working on a Dream salvageable or even, dare I say it, good?

I have to give Bruce credit for going full-on pop mode this time around. That's a shift that often alienates people but Springsteen seems to be long past the point of caring about hits and critical acclaim. That works in his favor and frees him to pursue whatever fancy may be on his mind; on the other hand it doesn't always lend itself to self-editing. What works here is pretty solid. "My Lucky Day" sounds like the kind of pop song Springsteen can write in his sleep but it's still fun and catchy enough that you don't really mind. "The Last Carnival" and bonus track "The Wrestler" manage to stand out because they contain the emotion and careful attention needed to make them effective.

"Outlaw Pete" is an ambitious opener, an eight minute romp that returns Springsteen to his storyteller roots and interesting instrumental flourishes. I like it more now than I did at first but it tends to drag on just a bit too long and loses steam after about five minutes. "Good Eye" succeeds in coming up with something interesting and its old-school blues sound uses Bruce's distorted vocals to its advantage. It's entirely unique to the album and has some grit that many of the other tracks are missing. There are glimmers of a good album here but unfortunately it never quite materializes.

The title track is decent but feels lifeless and uninspired, like Springsteen just threw it together and recorded it in one take. "Life Itself" and "This Life" are passable but feel rushed and devoid of any real energy. "What Love Can Do" shows some promise but passes by unremarkably; "Tomorrow Never Knows" is interesting but never really builds into anything memorable. "Kingdom of Days" and "Surprise, Surprise" are pure pop but manage to resonate with me on a basic level. They may be acquired tastes but in the right mood I can listen to them with ease. 

Perhaps nothing on the record feels so awkward as "Queen of the Supermarket", a tune so cheesy and overdone that it's almost laughable. The problem is that it takes itself too seriously and would have benefitted from a more quirky, fun arrangement. The sentiment behind the song may be sweet but Bruce's delivery and the multilayered production, not to mention some extremely cliche and corny lyrics, make it come off more like a parody than a testament to the beauty of hard-working cashiers. This one should have been relegated to a b-side.



The songs may not be the strongest set he's ever penned but they're hampered even further by flat production, leaving the band wallowing in a blurry mess of sound that fails to stand out or lend any sonic punch to these tunes. Bruce's voice sounds flat and distant, almost as if he's off singing in another room, bored and unattached to most of these songs. There's a lack of energy throughout much of this record that lends credence to the idea that's it's a rushed and unpolished effort that should have either been shelved or been reworked into something more concrete. It has a few keepers and it's nice to see him attempt some joy in his writing; the problem is that it never comes together as a whole. Instead of telling a great story it feels disconnected and tired. Some of these tunes are almost apathetic and feel like Bruce is on autopilot. Many of them are lacking the emotional resonance that they so desperately need in order to be effective. Lyrically they feel predictable and unimaginative, devoid of the usual depth and mystery that Bruce is typically known for. It seems clear that he wanted this release to coincide with Obama's inauguration but in the process he sacrificed some quality for timeliness.

I'll admit this record has grown on me slightly over time but I have to agree with the fans who had reservations about this one. It may just be his worst album to date (though I would argue that High Hopes might just take its place) and one where a few good songs aren't enough to hold up the weaker ones. I can enjoy it for what it is, which is nothing more than a rushed and mediocre pop album with a few decent tunes and many forgettable ones. I like it slightly more than I did at first but it's a slim margin. It's passable but not a record that I can defend the same way I can other dismissed records. It's okay---not even The Boss hits a home run every time.

Springsteen may have been working a dream but he would have been better served delivering a finished one.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Space Fact of the Week

10 Best Lyrics from Trouble Will Find Me

Underrated Record Club: Death Cab for Cutie - Codes and Keys