Album Review: "Hypnotic Eye"


After nearly 40 years in the business it's refreshing to see Tom Petty & the Heartbreakers still going strong. With Hypnotic Eye the group returns to a more rock-oriented sound but ultimately it feels a bit undercooked and derivative to rank as an instant classic.

There are some refreshing callbacks to early Heartbreakers records, namely in tunes like Fault Lines, All You Can Carry and Burnt Out Town. These tunes rank among the best on the album, blending the band's classic sound with subtle modern touches. This is where the record really shines and Petty sounds the most enthusiastic. Other tunes like the jangly Red River and the bluesy swagger of Full Grown Boy round out the group's influences. There's nothing new in these tunes but at this point Tom Petty has endured by embracing his trademark sound and adding small touches to it over the years. In that sense Hypnotic Eye is like visiting an old friend: it's warm and inviting.

That's not to say that everything works nearly as well. Lead single American Dream Part B displays grungy production and sneering guitar but doesn't manage to engage you beyond the interesting production. Power Drunk is a mid-tempo blues number that proves too plodding to its own good, while closer Shadow People ends the record on an underwhelming note. Sins of My Youth and Forgotten Man, along with the Southern rock of U Get Me High are all decent but I don't find them stuck in my head once the record ends. The album is also held back by the more politically charged lyrics, which is an odd choice for Petty when much of his discography has been geared toward escapism and personal stories that any listener can relate to. Maybe it's just me but hearing millionaires complain about "the greedy 1%" is tired and hypocritical. Tom Petty is a living example of the American Dream and if it were truly dead his band would have faded away a long time ago. His intentions may be good but lyrically this effort is a step down. The best moments on the album come from great storytelling, not from social observations. 

Despite the uneven nature of Hypnotic Eye it's hard to fault the band for still releasing material and touring constantly. It features some great tracks and some clunkers, a mixture of natural rock and forced structure. The callbacks to the band's early sound are fun and the country/blues aspects are a nice touch, yet many of them lack the big hooks and energy that you'd expect. It's worth a purchase for longtime fans but if you're expecting another Damn the Torpedoes or Wildflowers then you're expecting too much. It's decent but even middle-of-the-road Tom Petty is worth at least a spin or two.

Rating: 6/10








Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Space Fact of the Week

10 Best Lyrics from Trouble Will Find Me

Underrated Record Club: Death Cab for Cutie - Codes and Keys