Underrated Record Club #22: Weezer (The Red Album)


Weezer's third self-titled record, commonly referred to as The Red Album, is the release where it seems that Rivers finally let go of feeling Weezer had to be purely a rock band and could branch out into more experimental territory. Granted, this comes at the expense of a complete and fluid album but it does give the band some much-needed breathing room. In a day and age where many claim Weezer can do nothing right I find a good portion of their post-Pinkerton to be better than most give it credit for. The Red Album is a bold step forward for a band that was originally thought to be out of ideas.

"Heart Songs" is corny, no doubt about it, but Rivers does manage to pay tribute to many of his musical heroes in honest fashion. "Dreamin'" is wonderful, a roller coaster of shifting dynamics and tempos that is both personal and inspiring without every becoming too predictable. If anything this Rivers at his most personal and reflectional, something that hasn't been prevalent since the heartbroken storms of Pinkerton. Here Cuomo seems at peace with his life, something that may upset fans hoping for the angst of the past. Personally I find it refreshing and the lyrics, despite the typical cringe-inducing moments, do leave an indelible impression.

"The Greatest Man That Ever Lived" is the most ambitious tune the band has ever attempted, a genre-tripping adventure that never lets up. It may be an acquired taste for some but musically it's absolutely thrilling. "Troublemaker" and "Porks and Beans" are more traditional Weezer numbers that are decent musically and pretty poor lyrically. "Everybody Get Dangerous" contains a rock-rap structure that is equally silly and kind of fun as a guilty pleasure. The other three members get a chance to take the lead vocal spot on "Cold Dark World", "Thought I Knew" and "Automatic". It's another nice turn that gives the record a unique flavor, even if the songs themselves aren't terribly memorable.



I have to save a special place for "The Angel and the One". Not only is the album's brightest moment but it's arguably the best song Cuomo has ever penned. It's beautiful, heartfelt, and a fine example of just how great a songwriter he really can be when he isn't trying to write a pop hit or churning out asinine lyrics. He still has it, even if it shows up less frequently than many of us would prefer. 
The album is worth the price alone just for this track alone. 

It's not Weezer's finest record but it is a bold and diverse one. It was a bold move and one I would like to see them pursue more often. Fans may be divided on it but if you can get past having other band members sing, the goofy album cover, and some choppy lyrics then you'll discover a pleasant album that breathes new life into a band that many had written off.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Space Fact of the Week

10 Best Lyrics from Trouble Will Find Me

Underrated Record Club: Death Cab for Cutie - Codes and Keys