Harsh Words for U2 from a U2 Diehard


I love U2. I've made no secret about it. For well over a decade they've been my favorite band and have constantly challenged me spiritually and mentally. There's just something about their music and the emotional space they inhabit that touches me in a way no other artist has quite been able to do. I still remember hearing The Joshua Tree for the first time as a teenager. It changed my life and opened my eyes to what music really can be: cinematic, epic, ambitious, heartfelt, honest, and challenging. The fact that they've been able to retain that top spot year after year is nothing short of extraordinary, especially when you factor in everything I listen to. Everyone from Bjork and Miles Davis to The Clash and Neutral Milk Hotel occupy a space in my collection and I can find something enjoyable in just about any genre of music. I pour over music the way a lover of film devours classic cinema or the way a writer voraciously collects literature. We're all drawn to a certain form of art that touches us. For me that has always been music. From listening to playing instruments I can say my life would be very different without it.

Today Billboard posted an article saying that U2 will not be releasing an album or touring until 2015. This normally wouldn't be problematic except for a few major factors:

* The band has been talking about a new album since the summer of 2009. It's now been five years since No Line on the Horizon was released and we still have nothing, save for two songs.

* Recent tunes like "Ordinary Love" and "Invisible" not only excited fans but also managed to keep U2 in the public eye for the beginning of this year. Add to that a performance on Jimmy Fallon's first episode of The Tonight Show, an Oscar nomination and performance, and a Super Bowl ad and you have plenty of hype that has now been utterly wasted. Any momentum they gained has now come to a screeching halt.

* Bono claimed the band is working on two albums. The Edge said he had a busy summer up ahead. Larry claimed the album would come out at the end of 2013. Adam seemed dedicated to getting things off the ground. However, the band members always seem to be in different parts of the world at different times. It's hard to finish anything when you're not actually together and when your comments constantly contradict themselves.

Now think about this: how would you feel if the band you love continuously told you one thing and then did another? What if they claimed that they were hard at work on new material and yet never actually produced anything? You can dangle a carrot in front of a horse for a while; just don't be surprised when the horse eventually catches on and stops caring. 


These constant rumors and announcements have recently brought U2 fans to a boiling point, going from extreme excitement to outright frustration at the band's lack of progress and the seemingly endless hand-wringing that the band (mostly Bono) has done in worrying about whether or not the band is relevant anymore. Here's a surefire way to guarantee that you're irrelevant:

* Worry about whether or not you're relevant
* Don't release new material on a regular basis

U2 is guilty on both fronts. The general public has a VERY short attention span: take more than two or three years between albums and you're likely to be forgotten. All but the most ardent music fans will not care what you're doing after a limited amount of time. Let me ask you a question: how many people do you think downloaded "Invisible" for free during the Super Bowl? Judging by the numbers I would say a pretty sizable portion. How many are still listening to it now? Probably only the hardcore fans at this point, the very market that U2 should be worried about. We're the ones who will buy the new album in multiple formats, attend the shows, buy the tour merchandise, and line up outside record stores for new exclusive releases. At the end of the day the diehards are the ones who matter and it seems the band is more concerned with trying to appeal to a bunch of teenagers and moderate listeners who really won't stick around long after the initial thrill wears off. 

Taking five or six years between releases also puts an enormous pressure on you to deliver something extraordinary. U2 has raised the bar so high and waited so long that they now find themselves trapped by their own high standards and lack of output. They've backed themselves into a corner and it's sad to watch it eat them up. At this point their legacy is secure. They've sold more than 150 million albums worldwide. They've won 22 Grammys, tying with Stevie Wonder for the most wins by any contemporary artist. They have the highest-grossing tour in music history. They were inducted into the Rock N Roll Hall of Fame during their first year of eligibility. They've accomplished it all and should be proud of that. How about enjoying their later years and simply releasing what they want to release without worrying about how the market will react? That would ease their burden considerably. 

Artists like Radiohead, Bruce Springsteen, Bob Dylan, and Arcade Fire aren't concerned with public opinion or big hits, yet with each new release they gain more acclaim and more fans. They don't over-think their craft or worry what will happen and that empowers them to take chances that have paid off. Springsteen hasn't had a record shake the general public since at least 2002, although 1984's Born in the U.S.A. is probably still the benchmark. Radiohead doesn't give a crap about what anyone thinks. Heck, their last album was released by complete surprise and instantly garnered excitement because of it. Just imagine what would happen if U2 made a statement tomorrow saying that a new album would drop on Tuesday. Trust me when I say this: the hype would be massive. Their inability to adjust their marketing and promotion into more obtuse territory, as well as their failure to actively embrace social media, is holding them back from pioneering the current market. 


Many diehard U2 fans cite the 90's as their favorite decade for the band. While I've certainly been fond of all three decades I would probably have to say the 90's rank as my top pick as well. Aside from some amazing music it was also a time when the band, quite frankly, couldn't have given a (insert your choice of profane word here) about what the public thought. Achtung Baby completely confounded many fans and critics upon its initial release and Zooropa only served to further alienate those longing for 80's U2. Throw the dance and techno-inspired Pop into the mix and by that point only the most adventurous fans were still hanging on. The band continued to do whatever they wanted without remorse. Bono put on giant sunglasses and got into character on the Zoo TV tour, surrounded by dozens of television screens and satirized the public's fascination with new media and technology overload. PopMart saw the band take things even further by mocking consumerism and pop culture, all while having the band descend from a giant lemon while on stage. The public may not have gotten the irony but those who did understood what the band was doing and why it was necessary for them to reinvent their image. The heart and soul was still there but the colors were different. Relevancy didn't matter then, only the message.

I don't expect the band to repeat the past, nor do I expect them to do me any favors. I'm thankful for what they've given us and at the same time disappointed that they've wasted so much time over the last few years. Bono has been quoted as saying, "The world doesn't need another U2 album. We have to find a reason to exist." Objectively speaking the world doesn't need any album from any artist. If U2 never existed the world would still keep turning and life would go on. Sure, we would have missed out on some of the most uplifting and ambitious albums in history and stellar live shows, but the world wouldn't come to an end. The world doesn't need another U2 album...but we sure WANT one. The band members are older now and people understandably change with time. I don't begrudge them that. However, their lack of consistency with fans and constant delays don't show a band of confidence but rather one of fear and disorganization. Never before has the band seemed so aimless, unproductive, and distanced from who they are.

I love this group but I'm not a blind fan. I'm upset, frustrated, and puzzled by these recent developments. The clock is ticking and the band is in trouble. They need to forget about big hits, critical approval, and album sales. Those things don't matter and are more irrelevant than ever. I want them to focus on simply being U2, the fearless pioneers who do what they want and dive in head-first into the unknown. That's why I fell in love with them in the first place and it's what has kept me hanging on. When you attend a U2 show and see 70,000 people jumping up and down with tears in their eyes during "Where the Streets Have No Name" it touches something deep inside you. This band still has that talent and energy. It just seems that for the first time in their history they're no longer lifting us up but instead they're in dire need of uplifting themselves. They're human and I get that. I just fear we're in grave danger of losing this band if they don't get their heads out of the sand and start putting it all on the line. Let the pop kids have their Lady Gaga and Bruno Mars. You guys are better than that. Your true fans still want you. Why can't that just be enough?

As Bono once sang: "You can hold onto something so tight you've already lost it." I sure hope they haven't. 



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Space Fact of the Week

10 Best Lyrics from Trouble Will Find Me

Underrated Record Club: Death Cab for Cutie - Codes and Keys