Album Review: Teeth Dreams



After nearly four years The Hold Steady have finally graced us with their sixth album, Teeth Dreams. There's no doubt that this has been a long time coming and the end result is somewhat satisfying but far less interesting than some of their previous work. 

The LP opens promisingly, with lead single "I Hope This Whole Thing Didn't Frighten You" kicking things off in high gear. It's a solid rock tune, though for some reason Craig Finn's voice sounds distorted on the chorus. It's distracting and pulls you out of the song, a common problem that occurs frequently on Teeth Dreams. His unique vocals are constantly tweaked and laden with unnecessary effects that don't compliment the songs in any meaningful way. "Spinners" is one of the album's best cuts, a pop/rock tune that wouldn't sound out of place on a Counting Crows record, courtesy of jangley guitars and Finn's trademark storytelling. It's a solid start to the album and a worthy addition to the band's catalogue. It's a shame the rest of the album rarely scales these same heights.

The next few tracks are a mixed bag of distorted noise and wavering melodies. "The Only Thing" is decent, if somewhat forgettable. "The Ambassador" gives the record some much-needed breathing room and has traces of previous ballads like "Lord, I'm Discouraged", yet doesn't do much to really distinguish itself in spite of this promise. The soft piano is a nice touch and it's an element that would have been well-served by being included more frequently on the album. "On with the Business" also fails to really stand out, a mediocre rock tune that unfortunately feels too much like a throwaway tune.

 
"Big Cig" steers things back on course. It has just the right amount of lyrical intrigue and upbeat energy to make it worthwhile. Add to that one of the album's only big guitar solos and it all comes together wonderfully. "Wait Awhile" is a serviceable rock number while also feeling like a weaker version of "Spinners". Unfortunately it's too derivative to really stand on its own. "Runner's High" follows a similar path, a loud rocker that never really builds to anything spectacular. 

The last two tracks are where the album really comes around. The acoustic "Almost Everything" is wonderful, a bold track that makes me wish the rest of the album could have been sprinkled with this kind of diversity. The nine-minute closer "Oaks" wraps things up nicely and it once again brings much-needed diversity and laid-back atmosphere to the album. It never feels its length and harkens back to the classic sound that so many of us love about this band.

Teeth Dreams is neither great nor horrible; rather, it straddles the line and offers a few tremendous moments with a lot of passable ones. Finn's voice is too distorted with various echo effects to ever really connect and his storytelling, while still strong, feels more passive this time without strong music to really back it up. The gorgeous and energetic melodies of previous releases are largely absent, replaced by noisy yet clumsy arrangements. The departure of keyboardist Fran Nicolay has still left a massive hole in the band that has yet to really be filled. The Hold Steady were always a rock band that could think outside the box and transcend labels; here they seem to be comfortable in its boundaries. The group is capable of so much more and after four years we're left with a loud, raucous effort that comes off as more forced and less playful. 

This album is simply lacking the fun that made previous efforts so engrossing and memorable. Ultimately Teeth Dreams is all bark and very little bite.

Rating: C+



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Space Fact of the Week

10 Best Lyrics from Trouble Will Find Me

Underrated Record Club: Death Cab for Cutie - Codes and Keys