Second Listens: Monster (1994)
I'll be honest: this has always been my least-favorite R.E.M. album. It's not horrible by any means but it's a record that never quite connected with me despite having some amazing songs on it. After all these years I decided to recheck and see if my opinion has changed. The album cover is still cool, complete with that bright orange and creepy bear face, so that's a step in the right direction. Since it's a new year let's start with a fresh mind: has Monster worked its way up in my rankings?
Obviously the opener "What's the Frequency, Kenneth?" gets a thumbs up. It's just irresistible and manages to do everything right, plus it gets the odd mention for being one of the few songs to slip an f-bomb past radio censors. Listen to the end of the track and you'll see what I mean. Likewise, tracks like "Circus Envy", "Star 69", and "I Took Your Name" are all fun and melodic in their own right. These moments are when the LP truly shines and you get a glimpse of the potential this album had. Then there are tracks like "Let Me In", "Crush with Eyeliner", and "King of Comedy", which are decent but fairly forgettable and pass by without leaving a solid impression.
In the end that's the biggest gripe I still have with this record. It's not necessarily that the songs themselves are poor but rather that they're arranged and recorded in such a mundane fashion. Sure, there's a lot of distortion and dissonance but it's not enough to make the songs interesting. Unless you're a band like Sonic Youth, who's able to get away with noise experiments and random guitar tunings, it comes off sounding uneven and unnecessary. The band just never sounds comfortable or sure of themselves, which is all the more puzzling given their track record. Monster sounds like someone playing around with their distortion pedal but never knowing when it's appropriate to use it and when some restraint would be more fitting.
What's most interesting is that the two ballads on this album are actually the standouts. "Strange Currencies" sounds like a reworking of "Everybody Hurts" but it manages to add a bit more energy into the mix without going overboard. The hypnotic (and somewhat creepy) "Tongue" is gorgeous, complete with Michael Stipe's gentle falsetto wooing you into a sense of comfort despite the song's disturbing lyrics. In fact, this is one area where Monster is so fascinating. The music is fun and noisy, yet the lyrics are much darker and more twisted, leaving the listener to investigate what's really going on. It took me a while to realize this and it makes the album's shortcomings easier to overlook when you realize that the constant high volume of the music is a disguise for some unpleasant stories and depressing looks at society and celebrity culture. One thing this album does effectively is lure you in with a false sense of security.
This seems to be one of the most contested works in the band's discography, with some fans praising it as one of R.E.M.'s best works and others condemning it as a throwaway album with no redeeming qualities. Personally, I'm in the middle. It was nice to see the band try something unexpected and go with a heavier sound this time around; the problem is that it never feels as confident or coherent as you hope it will. The band sounds like they're trying to find their footing and aren't entirely comfortable with the new territory they're exploring, causing the record to jump from excellent to passable very quickly. Thankfully the follow-up New Adventures in Hi-Fi would remedy this and find the band much more comfortable with more traditional rock n' roll sounds.
I still find it to be their weakest album but that hardly relegates it to sitting on the shelf untouched. Half of the album is stellar and the other half, while nothing terribly special, is fun to listen to every now and then. Later albums like Accelerate would fine-tune this sound and harness its power much more proficiently, leaving Monster as an interesting stepping stone along the way. Time hasn't made me love it but it also hasn't made me apathetic to it either. I suppose that's better than nothing.


Comments
Post a Comment