Album Review: High Hopes
Bruce Springsteen's 18th studio album finds itself in a bit of an identity crisis: part new, part covers, part updated versions, it features a wide range of songs and styles culled from various material that's been sitting around for the past couple years. High Hopes will satisfy those fans looking for something new from The Boss but ultimately it feels more like a random compilation than another essential addition to his beloved discography.
The title track opens the album on a strong note, a flurry of funky rhythms and a strong horn section that help to give it a distinct flavor. It doesn't sound too far off from the tones of his last album, Wrecking Ball, and continues in the more experimental tone that album helped to usher in. It works well and is certainly of the album's more memorable pieces. "Harry's Place" is promising at first with its bluesy swagger and Bruce's gruff voice giving it some personality. Unfortunately it doesn't vary much and stays on a pretty straight course, making it a decent tune that invokes a bit of old-school Springsteen but lacks the energy needed to effectively pack a punch. Much as already been said about "American Skin (41 Shots)" over the years and by now you've probably made up your mind about it. Personally I've never cared for this song but for fans who have longed for an official studio release this is undoubtedly a big draw.
Things get back on track with "Just Like Fire Would". Despite being one of several covers on the album it manages to recapture the E Street energy of older albums and its upbeat melody makes it fun and engaging. It's proof that Bruce can still take someone else's song and make it his own. "Down in the Hole" begins softly before slowly morphing into a track that's part Nebraska and part The Rising, though not nearly as stirring as anything those albums contained. "Heaven's Wall" starts with a gospel choir before the band kicks in, all lead by Bruce's trademark vocals. It's a nice touch and it makes me wish the whole album could have been done in this flavor. It suits Springsteen extremely well. "Frankie Fell in Love" is serviceable and proof that after all these years he still has the ability to suck you in with a solid rock song coated in passion and emotion.
"This Is Your Sword" sounds like another outtake from Wrecking Ball and the subtle Irish influence is a nice touch. "Hunter of Invisible Game" is a tender ballad that's also a bit forgettable, a passable track that floats by a bit too effortlessly. Perhaps the most interesting selection for this album is "The Ghost of Tom Joad", the title track from his 1995 album of the same name. Here it's completely redone and it's one of many tracks to feature the work of Rage Against the Machine guitarist Tom Morello, who throughout the album adds in various guitar solos and effects. This interplay between Morello and Springsteen is certainly interesting and works well on this track, transforming the gentle acoustics of the original for a heavier rock version that's been played at various shows over the years. It doesn't add much to the album but at least fans can now have both versions at their disposal.
"The Wall" tells the story of Bruce's visit to the Vietnam Memorial in Washington D.C. and the impact it had on him. He sings about Walter Cichon, a local New Jersey musician who went to fight in Vietnam and never returned. It's a fitting tribute that finds Bruce back in his folk-singer guise. His cover of "Dream Baby Dream" is a sparse and soothing closer that I appreciate for what it is. It's nothing extraordinary but it's nice to hear nonetheless.
Despite the title, High Hopes should be approached with balanced expectations. This is a collection of random tracks written and recorded at various intervals and it shows. The E Street Band doesn't get much time to really shine, resulting in a record that's disjointed despite some great moments. The guitar work of Morello really dominates the overall sound and those yearning for Bruce's signature style will find it hard to come by, save for a handful of tunes. It's clear that Bruce felt strongly about these tracks and wanted to see them get an official release, yet he probably would have been better served just making this a compilation instead of a straight studio album. It's lacking the consistency and punch to elevate it to anything more than a curiosity for longtime fans and a forgettable experience for newcomers and casual listeners. Springsteen's at a point in his career where he can do things like this and that's okay. It's an interesting collection that's neither essential nor throwaway but rather somewhere in the middle. Let's hope this is just a stop-gap release and that something bigger and better is on the horizon. That's where my high hopes reside.
Rating: C+


Comments
Post a Comment