Album Review: The Best of Keane




Much like The Killers, Keane is celebrating their first decade together and The Best of Keane finds the band reflecting on their success and the music they've churned out over the past four albums and one EP. It's a good collection for newcomers but this one has something that makes it a must-have for the committed fans that shouldn't be missed.

Let's start with the standard edition, which is a single disc comprised of their biggest hits. Yes, I said hits. Despite the title mentioning the "best of", these are all pretty much radio staples. That's not necessarily a bad thing, as many of their most beloved tunes have climbed the charts at some period, particularly the songs from their 2004 debut Hopes and Fears. By now you've undoubtedly heard "Somewhere Only We Know" and "Everybody's Changing". They're solid pop tunes that have lost none of the charm and energy they had a decade ago. Other notable hits like "Is It Any Wonder?", "Silenced by the Night", "Spiraling", and "My Shadow" are all fine additions to the mix. There are no real surprises and that's one thing this collection is lacking. Some of Keane's finest tunes like "The Frog Prince", "Black Burning Heart", "Neon River" and "Sunshine" would have been nice additions, although I'll admit that's more personal preference and each fan is going to have their own idea of what a perfect collection should look like.

The two new tracks "Higher Than the Sun" and "Won't Be Broken" are both enjoyable, especially the former, which I loved right from the first listen. They're nothing revolutionary but they find the band doing what they do best: writing an engrossing melody that soars and leaves you feeling elevated. If you want just the hits and a good overview then this is a great place to start. However, collectors and big fans may find the bonus disc included on the deluxe edition to be worth the upgrade. Complete with 18 b-sides and various rarities, it's an absolute must-have for fans who want some of the band's more obscure material and it's nice to have them in one place. Those who have amassed these tracks through tireless searching and collecting may find it superfluous but for those like me who haven't hunted down these tunes it's virtually indispensable.

In the end The Best of Keane is one of the better compilations I've seen in recent years. The first disc is a bit too predictable but clearly the group felt strongly about these songs and newcomers will find it helpful in following the band's hits in chronological order. The real draw for the diehards will no doubt be the new tracks, bonus disc, and insightful liner notes. When you add those things in it becomes clear the band put a lot of effort into making this bookend to their first decade more than just a rehash. Here's hoping they have plenty of great music left in them for another volume down the road. 

Rating: B+

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Space Fact of the Week

10 Best Lyrics from Trouble Will Find Me

Underrated Record Club: Death Cab for Cutie - Codes and Keys