Album Review: Reflektor
You have to give Arcade Fire points for ambition. Since emerging on the indie music scene with the their lauded 2004 debut they've managed to become one of the most diverse and exciting bands of the past decade. All of this culminated in taking home a Grammy for Album of the Year for their third release, The Suburbs. They may come off at times as overly serious, heavy-handed, and a bit pretentious but I can't deny that they make music that sticks with me and clearly their ever-growing fan base is a testament to their talent for pulling people in with compelling music. At this point the stakes are higher than they've ever been and the band did a masterful job of giving us virtually no information about this record prior to its release. A subtle yet brilliant marketing campaign and a music video were about all we had going in. So can this Canadian tour de force pull off another ambitious effort, which happens to be a double album? The answer is, for the most part, yes.
By now most of you have probably seen the music video or heard the title track. It's a great opener and its disco rifts make it both danceable and slightly eerie. There's certainly a thread of LCD Soundsystem running through this LP and it fits the band quite comfortably. Songs like "You Already Know" and "Flashbulb Eyes" are remarkably fresh and bounce along with sweet melodies. "Normal Person" feels a bit more like their earlier material, a rockier and darker look at life that finds frontman Win Butler proclaiming "I've never really met a normal person." When I think about it I have to admit I'm not sure I have either and then suddenly the genius of the song begins to take effect. The first disc closes with "Joan of Arc", a raucous and driving number that manages to blend French backing vocals with Butler's solid delivery. It's a great ride and closes the first disc admirably.
Disc 2 begins with "Here Comes the Night Time II", a continuation of "Here Comes the Night Time" on the first disc. These songs give the album a bit more atmosphere and hint at the album's darker themes of isolation and death woven throughout the narrative. "Awful Sound (Oh Eurydice)" and "It's Never Over (Hey Orpheus)" are clearly sister tracks that flow well together. Butler has stated in interviews that the 1959 film Black Orpheus was a major influence and with these tracks he's given a new canvas to work with, complete with tempo shifts and dynamic ups and downs that make them two of the most fascinating cuts on the whole record. "Porno" recalls with 80's with buzzing synths, thick bass, and an electronic beat. It's uncanny how well Arcade Fire can adapt to nearly an genre and Reflektor is perhaps the best example of that. This is certainly their most diverse album to date. "Afterlife" and "Supersymmetry" are solid closers and bring the album full circle. Disc 2 is a bit quieter and more obtuse but that fact alone helps to justify the double album concept and it works much better than I was expecting.
This is a great album and a confident reminder of why Arcade Fire is has gained so much positive press. However, I can't just blindly give them high marks simply because of who they are and ultimately I feel this is a fun but somewhat bloated album. It lacks the energy and hooks of their previous releases, in many cases sacrificing melody for dance beats and tight grooves. The band is spectacular as always but they also sound more buried and distant this time around. This isn't bad but there's nothing here that excites me the way previous tracks like "Rebellion (Lies)", "The Well and the Lighthouse", or "Suburban War" do. It's lacking a certain something that repeated listens have not yet revealed to me. Don't get me wrong, it's great. I just feel they allowed experimentation to overrun melody this time around. That's not a bad thing but it keeps me from feeling quite as invested as I'd like. However, I can't deny that I love the textures on this record and what the band attempted to do. That alone is enough to keep me coming back. The fact that you can take it on the dance floor is a bonus.
Rating: B-

Comments
Post a Comment