Album Review: MGMT
I went into this release blind, having heard none of the songs and knowing virtually nothing about what how it would sound. MGMT is a duo that is full of surprises, to say the least, and this release is no exception. It's chaotic, loud, psychedelic, and free-flowing. Those looking for another repeat of their debut will once again be disappointed, as this picks up right where their excellent sophomore album left off. For listeners looking for something challenging and different, then this is a trippy and wonderful world to visit, if only out of curiosity.
"Alien Days" is a fitting opener, with vocals and atmospheric twists that help to make it sound as if it's being transmitted from another planet. Like most of the tracks presented on this record, it's ripe for interpretation and multiple listens to uncover everything it has to offer. "Mystery Disease" would have fit in well on Congratulations, its distorted drums and chiming synth work coalesce into something quite experimental and funky. "Your Life is a Lie" is a quick, noisy number that has potential but passes by too quickly to ever fully form. "A Good Sadness" helps the record recover with some spacey vocals and unique structure, as does "Astro-Mancy". "Introspection" is decent, a Faine Jade cover that's serviceable but nothing that couldn't have been filled by something else (though it does deserve recognition for sounding a bit more listener-friendly for those who want something more accessible).
"I Love You Too, Death" once again has potential but never gets off the ground, instead choosing to float by in a wall of psychedelic swirls and beats. "Plenty of Girls in the Sea" and "An Orphan of Fortune" both close the album on a decent note, though neither track is a particular standout. Producer Dave Friedman has the duo sound more than ever like The Flaming Lips this time around, although I think the Lips can pull this off with more confidence. MGMT sounds buried under the production and the album lacks the confidence needed to elevate it to greater heights.
One thing these tracks will make clear is the major recurring problem on the album: the hooks are few and far between. While the songs themselves are often fascinating and fun to listen to they're also somewhat forgettable, packed at times with so much production that the heart of the songs seems buried and almost non-existant. While MGMT has never been geared toward mainstream consumption they did always carry a sense of fun and structured pop that allowed their tunes to appeal to the public as well as the indie enthusiasts. Unfortunately this release is a cake with a lot of frosting but very little actual cake buried beneath. Couple that with another over-compressed and horribly mastered sound and you have a record that certainly stands out but only for a brief period.
It's fun to listen to and will certainly be receiving many spins from me; this time, however, it will be more out of curiosity and less out of love for the actual songs. I like what they tried to do here but after two years of production it sounds like a lot of tinkering and promising ideas without strong tunes to back them up. This group is growing and I admire that, yet they seem unfocused and unsure of what they to do and where they want to go. After two albums that had charm, hooks, and a clear direction it seems their third album finds them at an impasse between staying in the past and moving forward. Here's hoping the next installment will take the great ideas from this record and meld them into something more tangible.
Rating: C-

Comments
Post a Comment