Second Listens: Embryonic



Embryonic is an album I've struggled with since its initial release back in 2009. It's certainly not a bad record by any means and I love the adventurous, raucous nature of many of these tunes. However, that same sense of exploration also weighs the album down with some filler and half-finished ideas that sound more like b-side material than fully realized songs. Has it improved after nearly four years? Well...not really.

Let's start with what the Lips get right, which is quite a bit. Songs like "Convinced of the Hex", "See the Leaves", "Silver Trembling Hands", and "Watching the Planets" are sublime and wonderful, a terrific culmination of rock, funk, jazz, and electronic ambiance. They manage to squeeze some melodies into these tunes while keeping them in a more obtuse state. If you're looking for a record that requires multiple listens and a lot of digestion then you know full well that The Flaming Lips can deliver on that front, with this album being of their most bold examples. When the songs are good they're GREAT. I have to give a special nod to "The Impulse", which is downright wonderful and fascinating. These moments allow the band to really branch out while retaining what we loved them for in the first place.

Unfortunately there are also a decent number of tracks to wade through that really don't go anywhere. Songs like "Powerless" and "The Ego's Last Stand" fail to leave any prominent mark on the running order and come off as sound experiments included simply to make the album more difficult. I'm sure there's a good song buried in there somewhere but it never reveals itself. "I Can Be a Frog" features a cameo from Karen O but the whole thing is so silly that her unique voice is utterly wasted. "Worm Mountain" is a strong tune that features MGMT, yet you'd never know that based on the production (which I'll address in a moment). The jazzy, free-flow jams are okay for the most part and no Lips album would be complete without at least one or two instrumental journeys. There are several on Embryonic and they range from incredibly loud to soft and spacey. These tracks manage to keep things fresh but some are more interesting than others.

Like I mentioned earlier, the production is really what kills the experience for me. The Flaming Lips have earned a reputation for being a band that knows how to utilize the recording studio brilliantly and yet have mastering that ruins their hard work. Embryonic is over-compressed and full of clipping at every turn. These tracks are almost painfully loud and the obnoxious levels utterly destroy any sense of dynamic range. To have a beautiful ballad like "Evil" flow into the hideously loud and cacophonous "Aquarius Sabotage" will instantly have you reaching to turn your stereo or iPod down. I don't know why this group can't get decent mastering for their albums but this is arguably the worst out of all their releases. There are so many fascinating elements to these songs but the hot mix completely kills the intimacy and range needed to make them effective.

This LP marked another sea change for the band and I applaud them for continuing to move forward. However, this album is certainly bloated and the 18 tracks presented are generous but also unnecessary. Some of these songs have massive potential but never really get off the ground; by the end of the album it becomes a bit tiring. Add to that the horrible mastering and you have a great idea that comes up short on execution. It's a fun record to revisit every now and then just for something different but it doesn't grab me the way The Soft Bulletin or Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots do and it lacks their consistency. I've warmed up to some of these tracks over time but overall it's a record that I still have mixed feelings about. It's not their worst by any means but it doesn't scale the brilliant heights they're known for either.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Space Fact of the Week

10 Best Lyrics from Trouble Will Find Me

Underrated Record Club: Death Cab for Cutie - Codes and Keys