Popular Culture Isn't Actually Empowering Women
That's right, you read the title correctly. Now let's get a few things out of the way before I explain where I'm going with this:
* This isn't a rant for or against feminism
* This isn't a rant against the artists themselves but rather their message
* This actually does line up with the faith and music portion of this blog. I promise!
The inspiration for this article came from reading quotes from various female pop stars who claim that their racy videos and lyrics are "empowering women and freeing them sexually." The real tragedy of this philosophy is that so many women are buying into it and selling themselves short of what God created them to be.
I first remember hearing this phrase back in 2010 when Christina Aguilera released the video for her song "Not Myself Tonight", which is basically the soft-core porn version of her sexual fantasies. Or something. I really don't want to know. Just take my word for it: it's racy, even by her standards. This is nothing new, obviously. Madonna and other artists have been doing this for a long time and still continue to do so. Now we have other artists to carry on this misguided philosophy. When asked about the video Aguilera stated:
"One of my favourite videos ever is 'Express Yourself' by Madonna which came across as really strong and empowering which I always try to incorporate through my expression of sexuality [...] I love the direct reference I made to Madonna with the eye glass moment and the smoke and stairs. I was paying tribute to a very strong
woman who has paved the way before."
She's not the only one to assume that female strength comes from flaunting your sexuality. Rihanna and Lady Gaga have both made their share of raunchy videos and songs using blatant sexuality, as have many others. I'm all for freedom of speech and they are certainly free to do what they want. That doesn't necessarily mean it's a message that's beneficial.
Here's the deal: today's culture in general is sending out some terrible messages to women (and men but that's something I'll cover at another time). The myth that women who openly and publicly express their sexuality are stronger and more liberated is a sad one but obviously it's a ploy that has worked quite well. Sex sells and they know this. If they can get a suggestive song on the radio or a video that pushes the boundaries on the air then they have a better chance of catching your interest. It's basic marketing that's also disguised as some sort of empowering social message, even if that message is more vague and misinformed than anything else.
I have two main beefs with this. Okay, three since I just made myself hungry by mentioning beef. The main problem stems from these central ideas: showing off the "goods" to any man is not a sign of toughness and using sex to make your career prevents you from fully embracing who God created you to be. It's also hypocritical.
Let's deal with the hypocrisy first. I hear so many women talk about how they feel that porn and our sex-driven culture create an atmosphere of treating women like objects instead of real human beings with thoughts, emotions, and personalities. In this sense they are absolutely correct. What some of them, especially these stars, fail to realize is that they create songs and videos that are essentially the very thing they claim is damaging women. You can't accuse the porn industry of using women while making a music video that's a slightly tamer version of what they're creating. These women seem to be under the impression that because they're the ones creating it that somehow they aren't on the same level. It's a fallacy and it's hypocritical. It should be wrong for anyone to be viewed as an object at any time.
Now let's turn our attention to the "goods". Ladies, you need to understand something about men: you can't really find a good one when you don't make him work for sex. Now this seems primitive but think about it for a moment. Any healthy relationship is a combination of unwavering commitment and diligent work from both partners. If you simply allow the man to have you upfront without any work or commitment required then you've not only made it too easy but you've opened the door for him to leave or use you at will. It's like our culture has forgotten that a date consisting of nothing more than a decent meal and great conversation is far more valuable than 20 minutes in the bedroom. You don't gain anything permanent from bed hopping. That kind of meaningful intimacy occurs in marriage when you know your partner and yourself have a special bond and commitment to spend the rest of your lives together. Aguilera and Gaga may think that they're empowering women to use their sexuality but in reality they're creating an atmosphere where no mystery, no work, and no love ever enter into the equation. That's a slippery slope from which it's difficult to recover.
However, the biggest blunder these people make is using their sexuality for things God never intended it to be used for. He didn't give you that desire and that drive so you could show it off in public, pose in risque magazines, or share it with everyone who knows you. What this music (and culture as a whole) is teaching women is that they shouldn't be ashamed of their sexuality, which is something I also agree with. That being said, you can be proud of it while still keeping it under control. You really want to be a strong, sexual woman? Find a good guy who's interested in marriage and family and give that gift to him. The Bible is pretty clear that married couples have free reign in the bedroom to experiment, play, and be as wild and passionate as they choose. Ever read Song of Solomon? God only requires that it be between a husband and wife, be consensual, and be private. That's it. It takes true character and confidence to hold off and wait for marriage. Strong women don't use their sexuality as leverage, bragging rights, or as the basis for their career. What's unseen is much sexier and cooler than what you plaster all over the airwaves.
Ladies, you have so much to offer. I know because I married one and she knows better than to assume that what culture tells her about womanhood is true. You can enjoy the music and movies all you want but understand that it's made by women who are, on some level, either damaged or painfully unaware of who they are and what God, as well as men, really want. We don't respect the easy women or the ones who ask for nothing in return. We love the women who respect us and themselves and expect something far deeper than a one-night stand. You really want to be empowered? Keep some mystery and some self-respect. Trust me when I say this: real men want that, not a quick fix.
And for the record, I have no idea what Lady Gaga is wearing in that photo. You probably shouldn't wear it either.



Comments
Post a Comment