Album Review: The Weight of Your Love



Editors are a difficult band to place, mostly because they've changed so much over the past few years. Their first two albums were stellar but then they took a major detour with 2009's In This Light and on This Evening, a decent but ultimately uneven collection that found the band trying to experiment without much solid footing. I waited intently for their next release, curious about whether they could recapture the brilliance of their early work while experimenting in more subtle ways. That brings us to The Weight of Your Love, which has moments of excellence but ultimately lacks the energy and passion it needs to be a true contender.

The first time I heard the lead single "A Ton of Love" I got excited. Its blend of R.E.M.'s energy and Bruce Springsteen's passion gave me great hope that this record would be the band's return to form. While this track is certainly worth checking out it the same can't be said for many of the others. "The Weight" and "Sugar" both open the album on a decent note but neither song is particularly memorable and they lack any real hooks to keep you coming back. The orchestral flourishes of "What Is This Thing Called Love" give the tune a promising start but Tom Smith's use of falsetto immediately pushes the track into cheesy territory, making it sound more like Phil Collins or Journey than anything resembling Editors. His trademark voice is as strong as ever but it suffers when he utilizes it in ways that sound more forced and unnatural.

Tracks like "Honesty" and "Nothing" are decent mid-tempo numbers that neither impress or hinder. They're just there but pass by without leaving an impression. Things improve with "Formaldehyde"; it recaptures some of their energy and gives the album a much-needed kick that keeps it from flatlining completely. "Hyena" keeps the pace going and once again finds the band staying closer to what they do best. There are also hints of the group's more experimental edge, which tracks like "Two Hearted Spider" display quite well. The songs don't always work but they at least feel more well-rounded and fleshed out than they did on their previous effort.

The real problem with The Weight of Your Love is that it's simply not compelling. Many of the songs sound similar and they're lacking the pulse and tenacity required to make us care. I want Editors to keep growing and I certainly don't believe they should keep making their early records over and over again. However, they need to focus and find a sound to stick with. They have a trademark sound that doesn't blend well with electronic elements and power ballads, at least in the traditional sense. The Weight of Your Love is decent at best, a collection of mid-tempo, at times cliched, ballads with occasional stints in actual rock n' roll territory. I commend them for trying to tackle a more American sound but sadly they never sound comfortable or confident in the venture. Here's hoping their next adventure finds them in a place where the songs can rise up and display what this band is truly capable of.

Rating: C-

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Space Fact of the Week

10 Best Lyrics from Trouble Will Find Me

Underrated Record Club: Death Cab for Cutie - Codes and Keys