Underrated Record Club #14: Perfect Symmetry



There's no doubt that Keane was under a lot of pressure after the success of Hopes and Fears and its follow-up Under the Iron Sea. By now the band had established itself as a venerable indie/pop act and had quite a dedicated following, making it even more risky when they significantly changed their sound on their third outing, Perfect Symmetry. The album was met with mixed reviews and a considerable amount of confusion and disappointment from the fan community. Yes, I'll admit that I enjoy their earlier work a bit more but the idea that this effort is some kind of misguided failure is a silly and hasty one at best.

I'll readily admit that this was the first Keane album that didn't blow me away on my first listen. Upon spinning it for the first time I remember liking it but it didn't exactly suck me in the way their first two records had. After a few more listens it began to sink in and I warmed up to it as another wonderful addition to the band's catalogue. So what made it less accessible than its predecessors? For one thing, there's definitely an 80's vibe on this one. Those more accustomed to the band's use of piano and more subtle effects were certainly thrown for a loop when this album appeared. The piano is certainly still here but half of these tracks are guided by buzzing synths, whooshing keyboards, and looping beats. The upbeat pop of "Better Than This" and lead single "Spiraling" are definitely different from their standard sound and are bound to throw off more than a few listeners at first. "Again and Again" is a driving number where fuzzy synths carry the melody and bounce along with the chorus. "You Haven't Told Me Anything" uses them more reservedly along with Tom Chaplin's guitar, an instrument that had been absent on their other two records. It's pretty subtle on these songs but it's certainly there and, to my surprise, sounds pretty good. It adds a bit more instrumental polish to some of these songs and he's a more than capable player. His vocals are stellar as always and he has one of the best voices in music today. He gets better and better with every album.

Not every song is radically different. The album's title track is an epic, piano-driven number complete with big choruses and a choir of voices. "You Don't See Me" is a sombre ballad and classic Keane through and through, as is the closer "Love Is the End". The bouncy "Pretend That You're Alone" is also heavy with piano but allows the electronic influences to creep in at the corners, making for a perfect balance between old and new. "Black Burning Heart" is also more in the vein of their older material, sitting alongside more upbeat numbers like "The Lovers Are Losing" and the moody "Playing Along". I can't find any truly weak cuts on this record and each one is fun to unwrap and explore further.

Lyrically the album is solid for the most part, though there are moments when the words become a bit cheesy or preachy. This isn't really new for Keane but Chaplin sings them so convincingly that it's easy to overlook. Tim Rice-Oxley and Richard Hughes play as well as ever and that should also be no surprise at this point. They're a tight group.

There is one major negative to this record and that's in its production, specifically the mastering. It's horrendous. Yes, the songs themselves sound great but the loudness wars claim another victim with this release. There is NO dynamic range and everything is cranked to 11 in terms of volume and compression. As soon as "Spiraling" kicks in it's almost painful and you'll be rushing to turn down your stereo, computer, iPod, or whatever you prefer to use for music. It's the one sore spot I have with this record and it's a shame that the band didn't demand another mix to really showcase the new elements of their sound. Their other records had a bit of this but nothing as awful and blatant as the final mix here. It bothered me in 2008 and it still bothers me in 2013.

Aside from the sound issues, Perfect Symmetry is a winner in my book. It may lack the fun pop of their debut and the brooding atmosphere of Under the Iron Sea but that's okay. I don't expect the band to repeat themselves and as long as they can make their experiments work then I'm on board. Unfortunately they got too carried away on their next offering, the Night Train EP, and then got back on course with Strangeland, which was my favorite record of 2012. Give this one a chance and take it for what it is. It's a different take on their traditional sound but one that should appeal to most listeners looking for a new challenge and new horizons. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Space Fact of the Week

10 Best Lyrics from Trouble Will Find Me

Underrated Record Club: Death Cab for Cutie - Codes and Keys