Second Listens: Counting Crows - August and Everything After



"Step out the front door into the fog where no one notices the contrast of white on white/In-between the moon and you, angels get a better view of the crumbling differences between wrong and right"

A potent opening line if ever there was one, frontman Adam Duritz sets the scene for what we can expect from Counting Crows and their debut album: sadness, reflection, yearning, and longing. Those initial themes have always been at the heart of the band and twenty years later they still ring true to what the band believes. Released in 1993, August and Everything After is still considered by many to be the band's finest work, a perfect balance of honest expression and youthful dreaming. In the years since this albim's release the band has continued to make music without ever straying too far from the folk/rock/pop sound that made them a household name.

My first exposure to the band was buying This Desert Life back in the summer of 2000. I was instantly drawn to it and my fandom was pretty much set at that point. While I've always been a fan of August and Everything After, I've never quite been able to view it as the flawless masterpiece that many hold it to be. I consider the follow-up Recovering the Satellites to be my favorite, yet I can't deny the influence and the strength of their beloved debut. Lately I've been listening to this album quite a bit and decided that maybe I should look into it again. Does it still hold up? Can it eclipse my favorite and rise to the top? Am I asking too many questions? Let's find out.

The opener "Round Here" is certainly a highlight and arguably the best start to any Counting Crows album. The gentle guitar and Adam's delicate voice slowly give way to the rest of the band and their subtle entrance fully immerses the listener in the song. It's certainly one of their best-known songs and still a favorite at live shows, where it tends to take on a life of its own and can last anywhere from ten to fifteen minutes. That's a bit excessive for me but the original is still a true work of art. 

"Omaha" is a catchy pop tune that has always been a standout for me. It flows so effortlessly and it's like a warm embrace, a song you've known all your life even if you don't realize it. Everyone knows the hit "Mr. Jones" and you probably have your own opinion about it by this point. I really like this tune and it's probably the most upbeat and fun song on the record, making it a bright spot on an otherwise melancholy album. 

The next three songs are all ballads that really weave into the heart of the record. "Perfect Blue Buildings" uses abstract imagery to depict a state in which apathy reigns supreme. It paints a picture of a place where people want to be numb and lose any connection with their thoughts and feelings. Sound a bit heavy? That's exactly the point and Duritz is such an effective frontman for precisely this reason: he holds nothing back. This is also evident in "Anna Begins", a touching and honest look at a relationship (or lack thereof). Fans of the Crows are largely drawn to Adam's penchant for personal songs and emotional honesty, something that certainly drew me in when I first started listening to them and it's one of the major reasons I still come back time and time again. Speaking of that, there's actually a track called "Time and Time Again" and it opens with a gentle bassline before sailing into more familiar territory; a tune that's serviceable but nothing mind-blowing.

This is the one major issue that has always held August back in my opinion: the ballads are a bit too plentiful and many of them run at roughly the same tempo. These songs in and of themselves are certainly strong so please don't mistake this critique for contempt. They're great songs but after having three of them in a row the record begins to feel a bit tired and repetitive. The same can be said for the song "Ghost Train", which is probably my least-favorite song on the album. It's not bad by any means and it features some haunting organ work but it ultimately sounds like the songs we've already heard and it doesn't really add anything new to the album.

Just when you begin to think the the album is going to be all mid-tempo ballads, "Rain King" completely shatters your expectations and it's absolutely stunning. Its driving beat and Adam's soaring vocals, not to mention some of his most potent and vibrant lyrics, make it one of the record's brightest and most invigorating moments. The same can be said for the closer "A Murder of One", which rocks harder than anything else on the album, not to mention one of the verses quotes the poem that the band takes their name from. Nothing like a fun game for the trainspotters!

Two songs I want to point out are "Sullivan Street" and "Raining in Baltimore". The former is my favorite ballad here, a beautiful and haunting song that tears at your heart without ever feeling sappy. The latter is nothing but Adam and his piano and it's stunning, a grower that you may not appreciate on first listen but stick with it: the payoff is very rewarding. I also want state that the production is as perfect as they come. Every instrument is perfectly balanced and every song has a big, spacious quality to it. It should be no surprise that T-Bone Burnett was at the helm. He has a knack for making albums with this kind of quality and openness. In short: it's held up beautifully. 

Over a decade later I still enjoy this album. In fact, I love it now more than I ever have. If you want to get the most out of it then blast it during a cold and rainy day; it helps set the atmosphere and draws you into the head-space to truly connect with what's being played and sung. I still feel that the abundance of ballads slows the pacing down a bit too much but every song is strong on its own. You may not bond with it at first and that's okay; the Crows usually take some time to reveal the big picture. It may never become my favorite record of theirs but I feel like I finally understand August in a way that I couldn't before. That in and of itself is a special gift. Be sure to give it a shot and let that gift come to you as well.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Space Fact of the Week

10 Best Lyrics from Trouble Will Find Me

Underrated Record Club: Death Cab for Cutie - Codes and Keys