Underrated Record Club #13: John Henry



There seem to be two kinds of TMBG fans: those who think only their early albums are good and those who enjoy the band's whole discography. Often you can tell these people apart quite easily by finding out how they feel about John Henry, the Johns' fifth album. This is the point in their career where they ditched the drum machines and programed backing tracks and instituted a full band into their sound. This was the jumping point for many followers and the cries of "Sell outs!" began by a few bitter fans who wanted the same sound featured on album after album.

Now let's be clear: there are fans who don't like this album and yet still love a majority of the duo's output. Disliking John Henry doesn't mean someone isn't a TMBG supporter; it's the fans who feel that John Linnell and John Flansburgh haven't done anything worthwhile since that I find puzzling. All great artists change and try new things. Heck, it's been a staple of They Might Be Giants since they were first formed in 1982. Bizarre lyrics, unpredictable song structures, and ear-tickling melodies have always been the heart and soul of what they do. The do-it-yourself approach of their first four albums was amazing and I'm certainly a huge fan of that period, as most fans are. However, that doesn't mean I can't appreciate the new directions they've taken and how their sound has advanced over the past couple decades. This record was certainly a departure but not obtrusively so. There's a lot to enjoy here and anyone with an open mind will find the benefits of a real band to be conducive to the duo's songwriting.

If there were any doubts that the band had forsaken their roots, then "Subliminal" should come as a great relief. The first sound you hear on this record is an accordion, letting the listener know immediately that the Johns haven't lost their trademark spark. It's a fun song with the classic catchiness that you would expect from the duo at this point. Their early sound is prevalent on many tracks, including the fun (and informative) "Meet James Ensor", "AKA Driver", and the fan-favorite "I Should Be Allowed to Think". The clever lyrics are here in abundance, yet there's also a darker undercurrent that permeates the album and gives the songs a sense of coherency, a bit like the themes of space that were scattered on Apollo 18. John Henry is even more cohesive in its theme, which might have something to do with the skull imagery that's featured in the album artwork. It's even complete with children, which is both strange and kind of funny in a morose way.

It might be easy to write this album off as being too angsty or dark, yet I think that's a bit too simplistic. The sound and tone is a bit heavier than previous releases, much of which can be owed to having a real bassist and drummer thrown into the mix. This isn't an issue, mostly because they serve the Johns well. The sound of this album is full and rich, with diverse beats and great basslines that would have been difficult to replicate with the looping programs of their earlier work. The use of live horns is also prevalent on many of these songs, used to great effect on "No One Knows My Plan", "Sleeping in the Flowers", and the smart-aleck boasting of "Extra Savoir-Faire". This is a wonderful new addition to the group and one they've incorporated into nearly every album since. 

There are a lot of tracks that I love. "Out of Jail" is fantastic and features a disturbing storyline that just makes it even more memorable. "The End of the Tour" is a fitting closer to the record and a genuinely heartfelt track, territory that the band doesn't mine too often. "Destination Moon" and "Dirt Bike" are the kind of geeky trips that make TMBG so appealing to me, both clever and a bit silly at the same time. Of course, there are the usual strange and experimental tracks, mostly in the form of "O Do Not Forsake Me", "Stomp Box", and "Window", all of which display distorted vocals and unique structures. With 20 tracks running for nearly an hour, it's the longest TMBG album to date and even the pickiest of listeners will undoubtably find something they enjoy.

The old folktale of man vs. machine seems to be a fitting theme for this stage in the band's career. I can understand why some fans and critics might have had trouble warming up to this; the heavier sound and change in structure was certainly new territory. In true TMBG style, I believe they pulled it off and created a fun, diverse album that stacks up well with the rest of their catalogue. Initially I avoided this album after hearing so much bad press and outcry. Once I finally gave it a listen, I was incredulous at how much I liked it and confused why so many fans had been so harsh towards it. People seem to have warmed up to it over the years and I tend to hear more positive reaction to it now than I expected.

It's not their best work but it's definitely impressive and bound to put a smile on your face. As John Linnell sings, "Why must I be sad?". You can't be when listening to the Johns. Give John Henry a spin and see for yourself.  


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Space Fact of the Week

10 Best Lyrics from Trouble Will Find Me

Underrated Record Club: Death Cab for Cutie - Codes and Keys