Second Listens: Coldplay's "X&Y"



Another new section, you ask? Yes indeed! I was in a writing mood this afternoon and decided it was time for another music article, yet I was puzzled about what direction I wanted to take. I don't have a new album to review at the moment and no real opinions to bring up and bore people with. I need to choose which record to write about next for Underrated Record Club and I'm long overdue to catch up with the Great Debuts column. In the end I decided to be adventurous and do something new. This is a  new section will focus on revisiting older albums and seeing if my initial reaction has changed over time. Far too often we write off an album and make up our minds without really giving it time to marinate, resulting in missing out on great pieces of work that just take a bit more time and energy to truly appreciate. It's a lost art and one that, sadly, many listeners today simply don't have the patience to practice. I'm willing to admit when a record grows on me or when my first review wasn't accurate, so let's take this for a spin and start with Coldplay's 2005 release, X&Y.

I remember the hype for this record being huge. Early reviews were largely favorable and it seemed everyone was standing at attention, eager to get their hands on it. I certainly couldn't blame them for their enthusiasm. Parachutes was a great debut and A Rush of Blood to the Head was a perfect follow-up, marking Coldplay as one of the best up-and-coming artists of the decade. I wasn't bouncing up and down with anticipation but I was definitely curious to hear this new album and wanted to know if it could live up to the praise and massive hype. My first impression was a mixed one: half of the record was fantastic and the other half was dull and far too safe. I always viewed it as a mediocre album: certainly enjoyable but not terribly memorable or interesting. Do I still feel that way seven years later? Let's find out.

For starters, I have to say I love the artwork for this record. The cover is simple yet striking, grabbing your attention and instantly catching your eye. Using a graphical representation of the Baudot code was brilliant and definitely a highlight. The artwork certainly gets a thumbs-up from me but ultimately the music is what counts and that's where my true judgement begins. The album's first single, "Speed of Sound", didn't thrill me. It sounded too similar to "Clocks" from their previous album and never really built up to anything thrilling. Over time I've warmed up to it a bit; it's serviceable but not a destined classic.

The first half of the record, the "X" side, is the album's strongest part. "Square One" makes for a solid and engaging opening track. It sounds dark and atmospheric, giving you the initial impression that Coldplay is going for something grander and far more daring this time around. That may be true to some extent and it runs through the first side of X&Y. It's an energetic start and there's a part of me that wishes the entire album were built around this sound and edgier atmosphere. Fortunately, there are a few other songs that fit in with it. "White Shadows", "Fix You", and the Kraftwerk sampling of "Talk" are all fantastic and surge forward with relentless energy. Coldplay have often been accused of being safe and soft, something that I won't deny has been the case to some degree. However, tracks like these have a more daring quality to them that makes me realize the band is capable of more than they let on.

While the first six or seven tracks are pretty enjoyable, it's the second half of the record that really holds it back. The "X" side feels darker, heavier, and more ambitious than the "Y" half. While "Speed of Sound" gives it a decent start, it flounders fairly quickly. "A Message" is standard Coldplay: gentle, heartfelt, and a bit melodic. The following tracks, such as "Low", "Swallowed in the Sea", and "The Hardest Part" have the same problem: they're just not memorable. In fact, the hidden track "'Til Kingdom Come" is actually one of the album's highlights, a track written for Johnny Cash but was sadly never able to be recorded by him before his death. The album is strong out of the gate and falters by the halfway mark. It seems like the band was set on doing something different and more daring, only to rely on their trademark sound and some boring arrangements by the time it's over. In the course of the last seven years these songs don't sound any different to me. None of them are inherently bad by any means; they're merely average and feel like b-sides from A Rush of Blood to the Head instead of something truly groundbreaking. It's like the band got cold feet and second guessed themselves into treading ground that had been worn thin by this point.

Another weak point for the record comes in the form of Chris Martin's lyrics. Now let's be honest: words have never been his strong suit. I commend him for being honest and writing about topics that everyone can relate to. It's clear that his words resonate with listeners and I certainly count myself among them, yet that doesn't mean I don't want him to get better and branch out from the usual cliches and nursery rhymes that have a tendency to plague his work. On this record they're embarrassingly predictable, almost as if they belong on a Hallmark card. It really holds the record back and if the music had been stronger then they would have been easier to overlook. Just listen to "Twisted Logic" and the album's title track to get a better idea of what I'm talking about. I do have to give props to "What If", which is lyrically and musically simple but manages to overcome those shortcomings with some nifty production touches.

X&Y isn't a terrible album. It has its share of great songs and even the weak tunes are tolerable in small doses. The real tragedy is that I don't feel any different about this album now than I did in 2005. It had the potential to be huge and daring, yet it fell back on tired arrangements and predictable songwriting that should have been left behind. It's mediocre and it could have been so much more. Seven years later I still enjoy listening to it from time to time and it does bring back some fond memories from the summer of 2005. With the passage of time some records change and go up or down in my rankings. This one is one of those rarer cases where my initial feelings were correct. It's decent and in the end I suppose that's better than nothing. From here the band did step up their game and they continue to push themselves with each new recording. It's just too bad they didn't have the foresight to follow through on this record with that same enthusiasm.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Space Fact of the Week

10 Best Lyrics from Trouble Will Find Me

Underrated Record Club: Death Cab for Cutie - Codes and Keys