Album Review: Four by Bloc Party
It's been nearly four years since Bloc Party released their last album, Intimacy. Since then the band members have gone on to various side projects and for a time it was questionable as to whether or not the band would even reunite and put out another record. I've been a big fan ever since I first heard their stunning 2005 debut, Silent Alarm, and I've constantly admired the way they've managed to push themselves musically and continually challenge their audience. Four is a welcome return that, while not the knockout some of us might have been hoping for, affirms that this band has plenty of life left but that they're also trying to find footing in too many different fields.
Let's get this out of the way: this album is not Silent Alarm. That's a brilliant album and it's ridiculous to expect the band to keep making that album over and over. Some of that same energy is certainly present here but it's channeled in a very different way. The opener "So He Begins to Lie" perfectly sets the stage for what we can expect. The crunchy guitars and rush of drums are classic Bloc Party but they also have a weight and pacing about them that's refreshingly mature. There's also a slight problem with this song, and it's one that peppers many of the other tracks on Four: it doesn't necessarily build up to anything special.
"Octopus", the record's first single, is a prime example of this. It has an uptempo and danceable strut to it but ultimately it's not memorable the way many of their past singles have been. This is the one sore spot that I've had with this record: it doesn't stand out. The hooks are missing for the most part and the energy is all over the place, either feeling too forced or misguided.
That's not to say that everything here is underwhelming. "Kettling" is a monster of a song and sonically captures the noisy post-punk that made them so beloved to start with. "Real Talk" and "Day Four" slow the album down to pop territory but they work wonderfully, especially due to frontman Kele Okereke's gentle and gliding voice. His vocals are often pushed back in the mix this time around, causing the rest of the band to be little more than a wall of sound around him. In the right hands this is a powerful weapon but Bloc Party has always relied heavily on Kele's soaring and passionate voice to help carry many of the songs. His lyrics this time around are also much more vague, which is disappointing when you consider the depth and honesty he's typically known for. Vagary works for Michael Stipe and Beck but it doesn't suit the more upfront music that this band does so well.
"V.A.L.I.S." is the kind of track that feels instantly familiar. It's a bit difficult to describe for those not familiar with the group but if you're versed in their music then you'll instantly understand what I'm talking about. It's a lot of fun and one of the more memorable cuts on the album. "Team A" and "Truth" show some promise but slide by a bit too easily to stick in your head once they're over. The closer "We Are Not Good People" is a noisy and screaming track that attempts something heavy but just comes off as overdone and uncomfortable.
I applaud an artist for trying new things and Bloc Party has always been a daring group. Four isn't a bad record but it isn't a great one either. After four years the band seems to have gotten distracted by other projects and have lost that tight, focused sound that made them so exciting in the first place. I've been of the belief that this band is one of the best and most promising up-and-coming acts on the indie scene for years. However, this record doesn't really cement that legacy but rather barely keeps the fire going. This record simply doesn't know what it wants to be: pop, punk, metal, alternative? It just doesn't flow the way it should and it's hard to say who's at fault. Don't get me wrong: this is an enjoyable album and one that gets better with repeated listens. It just isn't enough to carry it from good to great, and at this stage in their career I know the band should be in the great category.
Rating: C+

Comments
Post a Comment