15 Underground Christian Albums You Might Have Missed
When you think of Christian music, what's the first thing that pops into your head? You probably have your own preconceived notions and you're not alone. As a Christian I'll be the first to admit that I find a lot of CCM to be somewhat corny and kind of dull. That's not a judgement or insult toward the musicians; just a personal preference. What you may not know is that there have been some amazing and extremely talented bands that slipped by the mainstream and were part of the underground Christian scene that was booming in the late 90's and early 2000's. I even made a mix-tape (remember those!?) for a friend in high school and he was surprised just how good it was. Contrary to popular belief, there were some pretty amazing Christian groups back in the day and if you're curious then here are 15 great albums you might want to check out:
1. Ace Troubleshooter-Self-Titled
2. Shorthanded-Forever Yours
Channeling The Descendants, Shorthanded didn't last long but this record is still one of the best to emerge from the golden era of Tooth & Nail Records. The production is solid and the band is tight, with all three members forming a fast and infectious combination that still sounds fresh today. The band didn't talk much about God or even spiritual matters but there was something reflective and urgent about their message that more than made up for it.
3. Dogwood-Building a Better Me
Building a Better Me is the kind of loud and ripping album that makes you wonder how some of these artists didn't become more well-known. This album was a revelation to me and still remains one of the most riveting and impressive records to my ears. At the height of skate-punk this record managed to infuse challenging, faith-filled lyrics with pure speed and unbridled energy. It's one of the very best and worth your time if you're curious about just how good Christian punk can be.
4. Five Iron Freanzy-Upbeats and Beatdowns
Five Iron Frenzy was one of the few Christian artists who found some success with more than just believers. Their mix of punk and ska caught on and their debut album is still an exercise in clever lyrics and a mixture of heart and pure silliness that defined the band throughout their career. "Milestone" is still a favorite of mine and what kid doesn't remember the video for "A Flowery Song"? For those who think Christians don't have a sense of humor and can't make interesting music, FIF might just change your mind.
5. Slick Shoes-Burn Out
If there was any doubt as to whether or not Christians could do punk music justice then Slick Shoes provided the answer. Burn Out is still a furious and fast-paced roller coaster ride that will make any punk fan happy, regardless of your religious beliefs.
6. The O.C. Supertones-Supertones Strike Back
Okay, I'm going to toss this out there: this may just be my all-time favorite Christian punk album. The sheer speed of these guys was truly incredible and they had one of the best drummers I've ever heard. What made the band so much fun was their song titles never matched the lyrical content. When you read a title like "My Leg Hurts" or "A Pirate's Dream", you can't help but expect the song to revolve around that topic. However, the actual song was always something else entirely and in the liner notes the band attached a Bible verse to every song. They were completely upfront about their faith and practically every song was heavy on theology and reaching a lost world for Christ. That may turn off the atheists and skeptics but anyone with an open mind and love for pure punk should try to hunt a copy of this down. It's one of the best I've ever heard when it comes to speed punk.
8. MxPx-Life in General
I'm conflicted over which MxPx album I would rate as their best. I lost interest in them around 2001 but it's hard to deny just what made them so special. Not only are they STILL going (something you can't say for about 98% of underground Christian bands) but they practically defined the scene and were the first punk band I can remember being able to appeal to everyone. Life in General is often considered their masterwork and while I might rate Teenage Politics or the collection Let It Happen higher, it's easy to see why this album was so successful. Everyone remembers songs like "Chick Magnet" or "Move to Bremerton" but it's the lesser-known tracks that always stood out to me, especially "Destroyed by You". Ah, nostalgia!
9. Plankeye-Strange Exchange
This is, hands down, my favorite Christian album ever. That's right. It's absolutely perfect and shows just how much Plankeye had grown since their early pop/punk days. Here they seem to be wearing more of a U2 influence and that's fine by me. What makes this record work so well is the subtext. Some listeners may not understand the true meaning behind songs like "The Way of the Earth" or "Bring It Down", but lyrically this album is incredible and the music is stunning. Definitely make sure to give this one a chance. It's worth it.
10. Reliant K-The Anatomy of the Tongue in Cheek
I included this album for one reason: it includes an epic cover "I Want It That Way" by The Backstreet Boys. That's really all you need to know.
13. Lugnut-Like the Dickens
22 minutes of crazy, loud, fast, bizarre, music is exactly what this album was. It was brief and absolutely strange but it's worth the journey if you can track a copy down. The fact that they did a tribute song about Indiana Jones should be enough of a selling point in and of itself.
14. Ghoti Hook-Banana Man
There were a lot of quirky, goofy bands dominating the scene but I'm not sure anyone could fully match the all-out freakout that was Ghoti Hook. Banana Man was a ripping good time and there were some great Christian-themed lyrics running throughout the album, sitting right along songs about loving your bike and going to the zoo. Yes, it really is like that.
15. Starflyer 59-Leave Here a Stranger
Starflyer 59 is still going strong and they've managed to traverse a wide array of genres, from rock to pop to blues to shoe-gazer punk to everything in-between. Leave Here a Stranger is often considered their masterpiece and it's a simple, luscious piece of work that anyone should be able to sit down and enjoy. The beautiful guitar work and melodies of "When I Learn to Sing" and "Night Music" should be enough to convince anyone. It's a stunning achievement and the fact that it was recorded entirely in mono is a fun fact.
1. Ace Troubleshooter-Self-Titled
Ace Troubleshooter's 2000 self-titled album is one of the most fun and infectious pop/punk albums to emerge from the alternative Christian scene. This record completely floored me when I first bought it in high school and over a decade later it still holds up. From the opening thrust of "SE 101" to the epic instrumental closer of "Fortress", this record is just about perfect and highly recommended for anyone looking for something with insatiable melodies and undeniable energy.
Channeling The Descendants, Shorthanded didn't last long but this record is still one of the best to emerge from the golden era of Tooth & Nail Records. The production is solid and the band is tight, with all three members forming a fast and infectious combination that still sounds fresh today. The band didn't talk much about God or even spiritual matters but there was something reflective and urgent about their message that more than made up for it.
3. Dogwood-Building a Better Me
Building a Better Me is the kind of loud and ripping album that makes you wonder how some of these artists didn't become more well-known. This album was a revelation to me and still remains one of the most riveting and impressive records to my ears. At the height of skate-punk this record managed to infuse challenging, faith-filled lyrics with pure speed and unbridled energy. It's one of the very best and worth your time if you're curious about just how good Christian punk can be.
4. Five Iron Freanzy-Upbeats and Beatdowns
Five Iron Frenzy was one of the few Christian artists who found some success with more than just believers. Their mix of punk and ska caught on and their debut album is still an exercise in clever lyrics and a mixture of heart and pure silliness that defined the band throughout their career. "Milestone" is still a favorite of mine and what kid doesn't remember the video for "A Flowery Song"? For those who think Christians don't have a sense of humor and can't make interesting music, FIF might just change your mind.
5. Slick Shoes-Burn Out
If there was any doubt as to whether or not Christians could do punk music justice then Slick Shoes provided the answer. Burn Out is still a furious and fast-paced roller coaster ride that will make any punk fan happy, regardless of your religious beliefs.
6. The O.C. Supertones-Supertones Strike Back
Their first album may have been cheesy and underproduced but The Supertones made up for it on their sophomore release. Back in the days when ska was popular in the mainstream, it also found its way into the Christian market and this album may be the best example of a pure and fun ska experience. The band's ability to address Christian issues with catchy and energetic music was a huge accomplishment and you don't have to be a believer to enjoy the wealth of talent and fun on display here.
7. Broken Cedars-Forever
Okay, I'm going to toss this out there: this may just be my all-time favorite Christian punk album. The sheer speed of these guys was truly incredible and they had one of the best drummers I've ever heard. What made the band so much fun was their song titles never matched the lyrical content. When you read a title like "My Leg Hurts" or "A Pirate's Dream", you can't help but expect the song to revolve around that topic. However, the actual song was always something else entirely and in the liner notes the band attached a Bible verse to every song. They were completely upfront about their faith and practically every song was heavy on theology and reaching a lost world for Christ. That may turn off the atheists and skeptics but anyone with an open mind and love for pure punk should try to hunt a copy of this down. It's one of the best I've ever heard when it comes to speed punk.
8. MxPx-Life in General
I'm conflicted over which MxPx album I would rate as their best. I lost interest in them around 2001 but it's hard to deny just what made them so special. Not only are they STILL going (something you can't say for about 98% of underground Christian bands) but they practically defined the scene and were the first punk band I can remember being able to appeal to everyone. Life in General is often considered their masterwork and while I might rate Teenage Politics or the collection Let It Happen higher, it's easy to see why this album was so successful. Everyone remembers songs like "Chick Magnet" or "Move to Bremerton" but it's the lesser-known tracks that always stood out to me, especially "Destroyed by You". Ah, nostalgia!
9. Plankeye-Strange Exchange
This is, hands down, my favorite Christian album ever. That's right. It's absolutely perfect and shows just how much Plankeye had grown since their early pop/punk days. Here they seem to be wearing more of a U2 influence and that's fine by me. What makes this record work so well is the subtext. Some listeners may not understand the true meaning behind songs like "The Way of the Earth" or "Bring It Down", but lyrically this album is incredible and the music is stunning. Definitely make sure to give this one a chance. It's worth it.
10. Reliant K-The Anatomy of the Tongue in Cheek
I know this one isn't that rare but I had to include it simply because of how great it was. Reliant K's ability to blend complete silliness with amazing insights is something not too many bands can claim. This album was fun and as slick as they come.
11. Huntingtons-Plastic Surgery
There was nothing special about these guys. Heck, they were basically just a copy of the Ramones. However, they did it so well that I didn't really care. Their music was fun, upbeat, and silly at times but it captured that awkward high school dating phase that we all endured at some point. This record was a nice mixture of what they could do and you can't help but love an album that closes with a song entitled "Mutant Monster Beach Party".
12. Fanmail-Fanmail 2000
I included this album for one reason: it includes an epic cover "I Want It That Way" by The Backstreet Boys. That's really all you need to know.
13. Lugnut-Like the Dickens
22 minutes of crazy, loud, fast, bizarre, music is exactly what this album was. It was brief and absolutely strange but it's worth the journey if you can track a copy down. The fact that they did a tribute song about Indiana Jones should be enough of a selling point in and of itself.
14. Ghoti Hook-Banana Man
There were a lot of quirky, goofy bands dominating the scene but I'm not sure anyone could fully match the all-out freakout that was Ghoti Hook. Banana Man was a ripping good time and there were some great Christian-themed lyrics running throughout the album, sitting right along songs about loving your bike and going to the zoo. Yes, it really is like that.
15. Starflyer 59-Leave Here a Stranger
Starflyer 59 is still going strong and they've managed to traverse a wide array of genres, from rock to pop to blues to shoe-gazer punk to everything in-between. Leave Here a Stranger is often considered their masterpiece and it's a simple, luscious piece of work that anyone should be able to sit down and enjoy. The beautiful guitar work and melodies of "When I Learn to Sing" and "Night Music" should be enough to convince anyone. It's a stunning achievement and the fact that it was recorded entirely in mono is a fun fact.














I'd toss in the Smiley Kids' album "Don't Get Bored" Awesome album!
ReplyDelete