Underrated Record Club #10: One by One--Foo Fighters


So wait: I've gone four months without updating this section? Not that anyone was looking for it but it bothers me. That's okay though, because at least I'm coming back with one heck of a rock album. Released in 2002, One by One was the fourth record from Foo Fighters and it also seems to be the one that's constantly slammed or dismissed by a lot of fans and critics. Even the band members themselves, especially Dave Grohl, have been critical of the record and felt that much of it didn't live up to what they had hoped.

I'll be honest in saying that I don't think it's the band's strongest album but it's also far better than they would lead you to believe. One by One is a slow burner but well worth the time and it reveals some pretty amazing things along the way.

Right off the bat we're treated to one of the band's best and most beloved songs. "All My Life" encompasses everything that we know and love about the band. The chugging guitars, pounding drums, thumping bass, and Dave's urgent, screaming vocals. It was a huge hit and remains a live staple at their shows. What really makes it fun is the roller coaster feel of it; it takes you in a million different directions and twists and turns through various changes and progressions. It's a trip and arguably the best opener to all of their records.

The momentum continues with "Low", complimented by Taylor Hawkins' furious drumming and some great metal-esque guitar riffs from Dave and newcomer Chris Shiflett. This was his first record with the band and he has a clean and melodic style that has served them well ever since. It has some real weight to it and the bottom end really carries it through. Foo Fighters has always had an amazing rhythm section and this song perfectly demonstrates how in-sync Hawkins and bassist Nate Mendel really are. "Have It All" is one of my favorites, a driving and fast-paced tune that has some great punk undertones. Again, all four members manage to come together and create a pretty remarkable song here.

However, it's "Times Like These" that really hits you in an emotional way. It's one of the most memorable songs from the album and it's upbeat message and music is truly a feast for the ears. Dave's lyrics are simple and yet they speak volumes:

I'm a new day rising/I'm a brand new sky to hang the stars upon tonight/I'm a little divided/Do I stay or run away and leave it all behind?/It's times like these you learn to live again/It's time like these you give and give again/It's time like these you learn to love again

These first four songs are the most popular from the record and the band seems to hold that opinion as well. However, that doesn't negate the other seven tracks. There's still plenty to love here, like "Tired of You", which features some guitar work from former Queen guitarist Brian May. The bouncy power pop of "Halo" seems to be channeling Tom Petty, albeit with a bit of a heavier tone and it wouldn't have sounded out of place on the group's previous effort, There Is Nothing Left to Lose.

Two tracks I especially like are "Burn Away" and "Overdrive", the latter of which is actually my favorite song on the album. That might sound a bit shocking, especially in consideration of the big hits and crowd pleasers found on the first side of the album. The song isn't anything special or unique but it's catchy and has a toe-tapping tempo that makes it stick in your head. It's fun and definitely an underrated gem.

It's not all perfect. "Disenchanted Lullaby" is a good tune but it never quite gets off the ground the way you hope it will. "Lonely as You" is solid, though nothing terribly memorable and the seven minute closer "Come Back" feels too weighty and meandering. Again, none of these songs are bad or unpleasant but they don't feel as tight and confident as they should. I also have an issue with the sound of this record, especially the drums. For some reason they sound too "tinny" and muddled. I'm not sure exactly why this is but they lack the usual kick (pardon the pun) that we're used to from Foo Fighters records. Maybe it's just me.

Overall, One by One is loud, gritty, dark, and deserving of so much more than it's given. It's not perfect by any means but it's a strong follow-up to the band's 90's material, a set of records which any group would be hard pressed to live up to. It won't hit you at first but repeated listens reveal a complex and worthy addition to the band's catalogue. Give this one a chance because it'll stick with you far longer than you might think.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Space Fact of the Week

10 Best Lyrics from Trouble Will Find Me

Underrated Record Club: Death Cab for Cutie - Codes and Keys