Album Review: The Stars Are Indifferent to Astronomy by Nada Surf


This album has been out for a few months but I wanted to wait and give it plenty of time to settle in before writing a review. Nada Surf albums are often growers and require quite a few spins for me to fully digest and this record is certainly no exception. The band's first album of new material since 2008's Lucky is a tight and bright collection of songs that continues to add to the band's already impressive and consistent catalogue of music. 

One thing the band said they wanted to do on this record was capture the raw energy of their live shows. In that regard The Stars Are Indifferent to Astronomy hits the mark perfectly. This album is loud and care-free, rolling from one song to the next almost as if you were watching a live performance. The opener "Clear Eye Clouded Mind" blasts through your speakers the instant you push play and its urgency harkens back to the band's earlier records in the late 90's. 

If you want upbeat rock songs then this is the Nada Surf album for you. Typically their records are known for having a nice balance of tender ballads and driving pop songs. That formula is eschewed here for a more in-your-face approach and at first this is a bit surprising. In fact, only two songs, "Let the Fight Do the Fighting" and "When I Was Young", could really be described as mid-tempo ballads. The other eight tracks here demand to be played loud and they reach out in a wall of sound and soaring melodies. 

This isn't a bad thing by any means. "Waiting for Something", "Looking Through", and "No Snow on the Mountain" are a few of the tracks that recall Nada Surf's signature melodic sound. "Teenage Dreams" is a bit on the cheesy side but the music is enough to carry it while "The Future" is a decent but somewhat underwhelming closer. Matthew Caws' voice is as featherlight as ever and he's lost none of his signature tone over the years. He creates an intimate and personal space with his voice that few other vocalists can do so easily and he's in fine form once again. Lyrically the album is optimistic and reflective, though that should be no surprise. Caws has never been one for the doom and gloom approach that a lot of other indie bands have. He doesn't shy away from the tough issues but ultimately there has always been a joy and maturity to the band's music and lyrics that I have always admired. At times the lyrics are a bit on the corny side but it's nothing too distracting.

The rest of the band sounds energized and vibrant as well. Bassist Daniel Lorca plays with his usual finesse and drummer Ira Elliot pounds away with a ferocity that we haven't heard since The Proximity Effect back in 1998. While this enthusiasm works in the record's favor, it also makes the album as a whole feel a bit rushed. There are no real standout songs here, so don't expect something like "Always Love" or "Hyperspace" here. This is the one aspect of the record that disappointed me just a bit. My favorite Nada Surf releases are the ones that find a wonderful blend between soft and loud, fast and slow, thoughtful and fun. This record has some of that but it also bleeds together a bit too cleanly and that's one reason why I needed to wait to write this. I was disappointed at first but over the last few months I've begun to see what this record has to offer and overall it's solid, if a bit blurry around the edges.

The Stars Are Indifferent to Astronomy is another solid effort from the group. It falls in line with the sound they're best known for, so don't expect a major reinvention or surprise here. It's louder and brisker than some of their previous work but it's still Nada Surf through and through. It isn't their finest album by any means but it's still great to be getting music from these guys after all these years. In a day and age filled with throwaway pop and forgettable, shallow rock acts it's comforting to find a band that rises above it and delivers something deep, mature, and uplifting. They've grown up a lot since they first came on the scene and I'm grateful. I've grown too and it's nice to find music that not only understands this but encourages it.

Rating: C+

Comments

  1. I've never heard of this group, but the way you wrote this up makes me want to go out and get this. SMOOTH!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Space Fact of the Week

10 Best Lyrics from Trouble Will Find Me

Underrated Record Club: Death Cab for Cutie - Codes and Keys