Album Review: Port of Morrow by The Shins


It's hard to believe that it's been five years since the last Shins album, Wincing the Night Away. A lot has changed in that amount of time, including the band's lineup. Frontman and songwriter James Mercer is the only original member, disbanding the rest and replacing them with new session players. Mercer has always been the driving force behind the group and opinions have been divided about whether he was justified in taking even more control. I'm not here to debate that or give my own opinion on the situation; I don't know enough about what happened behind the scenes and in the end this review isn't a commentary on the actual band but on the music. Thankfully, Port of Morrow delivers in this area, giving us a taste of what we've come to love about the band while simultaneously throwing some curve balls into the mix as well.

Wincing the Night Away is, to my humble ears, a masterpiece through and through. It's one of my all-time favorite records and it got me through a very difficult time in my life, a favor for which I will always be grateful. That's a lot of pressure to live up to and Port of Morrow isn't on the same level. Each Shins album is different and follows its own trajectory and sound, making it a bit difficult to compare them to each other. This record has been labeled as a James Mercer solo project by many and I can certainly understand that claim to some extent. However, I also got that feeling from their previous records as well so maybe I'm not too surprised. In any case, this album continues the sonic experimentation that Wincing the Night Away began and there are some really wonderful moments to be found in the soundscape of this record.

"Simple Song" was a smart choice for a first single. It's extremely catchy and more reminiscent of the band's previous work. Mercer has a great ear for melody and that's always been one of the biggest staples of the band: simple songs that are extremely melodic and smart. I have to admit that this song is a also a bit of red herring, as there's nothing else on the record that's quite as catchy and accessible as this. The opener "The Rifle's Spiral" features some fantastic instrumental work and it continues to push the band's sound in more obtuse and daring directions. I personally love this change but fans looking for another "Caring is Creepy" or "Pink Bullets" will probably be disappointed, as there's nothing quite as direct here.

"Bait and Switch" contains a funky melody that hides some subtle Caribbean influences. "No Way Down" is about as close to a mainstream pop song as Mercer has ever come, yet he makes it work by throwing in some great guitar work that anchors the song in more familiar indie territory. "It's Only Life" and "September" are tender ballads that look on the bright side, a nice about-face compared to Mercer's more sombre and, at times, less optimistic lyrics. Speaking of lyrics, they're strong here but also lacking some of the wit and clever wordplay of the past. They're still thoughtful but also more direct and simple this time around, something that doesn't affect me too much but will probably disappoint fans looking for the lyrical twists and humor of past albums.

The second half of the record feels more familiar. "For a Fool" is a sauntering country-esque number that might have fit in on Chutes Too Narrow. "Fall of '82" features some keyboard work more reminiscent of their debut, Oh, Inverted World , and then randomly throws in a trumpet that lifts the song to exciting new heights. "40 Mark Strasse" reminds me of something Elvis Costello might pen and the album's title track feels like it's channeling Radiohead, adding even more diversity to the end of the album. The ten tracks on this album are all good, though there aren't really any songs that stand out, with the exception of maybe "Simple Song". It's much more of an album experience and I really like that about it. In a day and age of cherry picking and people downloading only one or two songs, it's great to see an artist still devoted to making the album a complete and immersive experience.

Port of Morrow isn't Mercer's strongest work but it's still a welcome breath of fresh air. Five years was a long time to wait and no doubt this album will be judged more harshly because of the buildup to it. Mercer's work with Broken Bells and other projects has definitely influenced this record and those expecting a traditional Shins album will be sorely let down. If you approach this one with an open mind and are willing to accept the change and growth that this band is experiencing then you'll find a great summer album that reminds us why we were drawn to this band in the first place.

Rating: B-

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Space Fact of the Week

10 Best Lyrics from Trouble Will Find Me

Underrated Record Club: Death Cab for Cutie - Codes and Keys