Cover Albums: Really?

Okay, I have to rant a little bit here about something that bothers me: cover albums. You know those, right? It's where an artist puts out an album of them covering other artists. Over the past few years these seem to be more common and honestly I'm getting tired of them. Let me state my case for this:

First off, I'm not totally opposed to them. They can be interesting and it's always wonderful to see artists paying tribute to those that have inspired them. In this respect I can understand their value and I'm sure they're fun and fairly easy to record, thus making things easier for some musicians and giving them a much-needed break from writing their own material. I can totally sympathize with that.

However, I do get a bit irked when a covers album is released in the place of original material. Here's the difference:

Back in 1981 Elvis Costello released Almost Blue, an album of old country covers. It was a puzzling and unconventional move but it worked. Not only is it a good album but Elvis also released Trust that same year, an album of original material, not to mention he released Get Happy!! in 1980 and Imperial Bedroom in 1982. Even if you didn't care about the country album, you still had plenty of options and output to keep you satisfied.

Nada Surf is another example. In 2010 they released If I Had a Hi-Fi , a cover album from some of their favorite artists. I wasn't really excited about it but they released a new album this year and their last album came out in 2008. Again, we didn't have to wait too long for something new. When cover albums are more of a side project or stop-gap album then I find them much easier to deal with.

What originally got me thinking about this was the latest release from Counting Crows, entitled Underwater Sunshine. I've been a big Crows fan for over a decade and I always look forward to seeing where Adam Duritz and the band will go next. When I heard the news that the band was working on new album I got excited...until I learned it was a cover album.

Now normally I would just overlook this but typically the band only releases a new album about every four years. They last came out in 2008 and after four years I was disappointed to learn that after all this time we're simply getting a collection of them performing other people's songs. Now don't get me wrong: the band is free to do what they want and I have no problem with that. It's just a bit disheartening that after waiting all this time that's what we're getting and it'll most likely be another few years before they record another album.

It seems like more and more artists are taking this route. Even older artists like Eric Clapton and Phil Collins are doing this; they simply release a cover album and just wait an eternity to put something new out. Is it laziness? Maybe. I have no doubt that they're fun and easy to record but is that really fair to make your fans wait for years only to give them songs they've heard before that were written by someone else? I don't know. It's a slippery slope and I find myself conflicted and confused by it.

Oh well. The wait for 2016 begins I suppose!

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Space Fact of the Week

10 Best Lyrics from Trouble Will Find Me

Underrated Record Club: Death Cab for Cutie - Codes and Keys