Achtung Baby Reissue: A Missed Opportunity?
If you're a diehard U2 fan like I am then the photo above is impressive beyond words. Chances are you've heard about it by now: at the end of October U2 will be reissuing a 20th anniversary edition of their landmark Achtung Baby album. Out of the five different editions being released the most expensive is the "Uber Deluxe Edition", complete with everything you see above. It's exciting and tempting to be sure, yet the more I read about it the more I realize that I can live without it.
So far the U2 remasters have been beyond fantastic in terms of sound, packaging, and execution. Their catalogue has been long overdue to receive this kind of treatment and over the past few years they've slowly begun to give their discography the special attention it so badly needed. I've been extremely pleased with all of them and was anxiously awaiting to see what the band would do with Achtung Baby. However, I have to admit that I'm a bit disappointed and fans across the internet have had mixed reactions to this release for numerous reasons. While the options and packages look great, it seems like the actual music is suffering for this one and I'm really puzzled by it all.
For starters, it was originally announced that both Achtung Baby and its follow-up Zooropa would be released at the same time. To an extent this is true; however, Zooropa isn't getting a separate release and can only be found in one of the two larger box sets. I'm not sure why this album, arguably the band's most bizarre, experimental, and groundbreaking, is being treated as little more than an afterthought. Why not give it an individual release like all the others since it's a fan-favorite and is clearly a different and stand-alone album? Unless the band is planning on releasing it by itself later on then it seems like it's simply being included as an afterthought and that's a bit disheartening.
It also appears that the extras, while interesting, aren't anything terribly different from what we've heard before. There are naturally some unreleased tracks and demos being included that any fan would be thrilled to get, yet the huge price of the set (the highest being somewhere around $600) doesn't justify the rare tracks. I don't need an entire disc of remixes or of material that I've had for years. This was a prolific and experimental phase for the band and there have to be many more goodies stilling on a shelf somewhere. I don't believe that the final track-listing has been confirmed yet but judging from what I've seen I don't see enough new material to warrant the high price. Many of the demos are the kind of thing I would listen to once or twice and then probably forget about. It's really the unreleased songs that I care about and I'm not seeing the abundance of them here that I was expecting.
However, the thing that disappoints me the most is that, according to all sources at this point, neither of these albums are being remastered. This is simply a stunning thing to me. As an audiophile and music-lover I've really enjoyed hearing so many older albums get an updated and clean sound thanks to modern technology. The Edge has supervised all of the band's remasters and they all sound wonderful: they're clear, warm, and a bit louder without succumbing to over-compression and a loss of dynamic range. Both Achtung Baby and Zooropa, while being recorded digitally, are still in desperate need of updating. The discs sound muffled and muddy in places and really could use some cleanup and the volume could afford to be cranked up just a tiny bit. It wouldn't take much to bring out all the subtleties and wonderful sounds on these albums and for some reason it appears that the band didn't think it was necessary.
Now granted, they made these albums and their knowledge of music far exceeds my own so I'm in no place to judge. Still, for albums that are two decades old it just makes sense to remaster them and make them compatible with today's technology. It's just really astounding that they would put all this time and effort into this release and not have it remastered. I just can't get past it and it doesn't make sense to pay for an album that I already have that sounds EXACTLY the same. Unless they come out and announce something different before October then it appears that the albums I own are the ones I'll be sticking with because the sound will be comparable.
I can't deny that these sets look wonderful and the packaging and extras are pretty neat. However, in the end it's the music the matters the most to me and apparently what's included matches up with what I already have. I may buy one of the cheap editions just to get a few of the bonus tracks but other than that it appears my old and worn out copies Achtung Baby and Zooropa are the ones I'll be sticking with. I'm sure a lot of fans will eat these up and that's fine; everyone's different and fandom isn't measured by material objects or money. I'm as big a fan as anyone else but that doesn't mean I'm going to put down my hard-earned money on something that I essentially already own. Here's hoping the band take the time to remaster these great albums and give us some more bonuses worthy of the wonderful music they've made.
Comments
Post a Comment