We Can't We Allow Artists to Evolve? (Installment 2)

Last week I wrote an article about Weezer and how I felt it was unfair for fans and critics to constantly criticize the band for changing and evolving in their sound and lyrics. However, Weezer is far from the only band to deal with this. One of my all-time favorite bands, R.E.M., has come up against similar criticisms and complaints as well.

R.E.M.


Much like Weezer, R.E.M. began their career at such a profound and stellar level of creativity that they've been judged against it ever since. When Murmur was released in 1983 it immediately set the bar high. In fact, the album's title is somewhat ironic because it started the band's run off with a bang. This began their stint on the IRS record label, commonly referred to as the "IRS Years" by fans. This lasted from 1983-1987 and included Murmur, Reckoning, Fables of the Reconstruction, Lifes Rich Pageant, and Document. Few fans or critics will argue against this era and many claim the band was at their artistic peak and you'll find plenty of detractors who believe the band went downhill after this point and never recovered. I'll admit that their IRS albums are some of their finest and those five records are undeniable classics. In fact, Fables of the Reconstruction is arguably my favorite R.E.M. album. Those albums are indeed brilliant and contain so many classics and wonderful tunes.

However, their brilliance doesn't negate the rest of the band's catalogue and it's at this point that the group began to expand and grow. Albums like Green and Out of Time found the band experimenting with pop, rock, and even country, not to mention they spawned classic hits like "Losing My Religion", "Orange Crush", and "Stand". The energetic and jangly sound of the band's earlier work was still there; it was just re-channeled and expanded upon in the way you would expect any growing and mature artist to do.

Automatic for the People was released in 1992 and to this day it's still hailed as one of their crowning achievements. This album is a masterpiece in every sense of the word and every music lover should hear this album at least once in their life. It's beautiful, haunting, devastating, and masterfully crafted. Much like their early records, it seems that every R.E.M. release since then gets compared to this album. With every new record I read reviews that say, "It's their best since Automatic for the People" or "Not since 1992 has the band sounded this great". Again, there's no denying the brilliance of that album but that was just one phase of the band and it's unfair to expect them to be making that same type of music 20 years later.

After that the group experimented with heavier rock with the albums Monster and New Adventures in Hi-Fi. Some fans claim that the band lost them at this point and they've never come back while others view it as a daring and exciting time in the band's career. I'll be the first to admit that I think New Adventures in Hi-Fi is one of the band's best albums and it illustrates perfectly what a tight and energetic band they were.

However, in 1997 drummer Bill Berry announced that he was leaving R.E.M., causing the other three members to consider how to proceed. They carried on as a trio and released Up in 1998. While you'll find complainers throughout the band's career, it's this album that many consider to be the start of their "downfall". Up was heavy on electronic influences and featured a more layered and melancholy sound than its predecessors. It's a great album but for those expecting the bright and upbeat tunes of the past then it threw them a major curveball and it was met with mixed reception.

2001 saw the release of Reveal, another record which I can say might just be my favorite R.E.M. release. Its bright, summertime pop makes it the perfect album for summer days and its lush production makes it a warm and inviting experience. The single "Imitation of Life" became a hit and at the time many claimed it was a "return to form" to the band's more classic sound. This still wasn't enough to please some people and the follow-up Around the Sun has become the band's most maligned and trashed record. I already wrote an entire article about why I think it's underrated so I won't rehash those points here. Simply put: it's not their best but it's far from the disgrace that people make it out to be. If you give it a chance you'll find some wonderful music on it.

The band's most recent albums, Accelerate and Collapse Into Now, have garnered better reviews and seem to have won over new fans as well as those who jumped ship years ago. R.E.M. are still putting out fantastic music but it's sad that many fans simply dismiss so much of their output. Have they changed? Absolutely. Is that a good thing? Without a doubt. As great as their early albums are, I don't want those some albums repeated again and again. I love the fact that Michael Stipe and the rest of the band make the kind of music they want to make and are relatively unconcerned with what people expect or think about their music. The people who gripe about anything post-1997 are missing out on some of the band's most beautiful, challenging, and exciting work.

I'm a fan of the band's whole discography. Sure, some records are better than others and I have my personal favorites but that doesn't mean I haven't found something wonderful and inspiring in all their work. Every album has its fair share of fantastic tunes and daring departures. The band has changed and grown but they've never lost the heart of who they are and what they believe. If the naysayers don't want to accept that then they're welcome to continue living in the past. As for me, I'm still enjoying this band and I'm more than happy to collapse into now.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Space Fact of the Week

10 Best Lyrics from Trouble Will Find Me

Underrated Record Club: Death Cab for Cutie - Codes and Keys