We Can't We Allow Artists to Evolve? (Installment 1)

There seem to be two types of music lovers that I run into. There's the first camp, who we'll simply label as the "Stuck in the Past" group. These people fear musical change. Anytime an artist they love does anything even minutely different from the norm they freak out and talk about how the artist sold out or lost their way. Then you have the "It Must Be Different Every Time" category. These people want every new song or album to be a complete departure from what came before and if it isn't then they accuse the artist of playing it safe and not progressing. Lately I've had several of my favorite artists take on these criticisms and I want to cut through the muck and get to the heart of how I feel about music and whether these claims are authentic.

To begin with, I fall somewhere in the middle. I enjoy artists who try new things and who do the unexpected. It's one reason why artists like U2, Beck, Radiohead, and Elvis Costello are some of my all-time favorites. I can never predict from one release to the next what they'll do or what direction they'll sail in. It's always a musical adventure with them and one I'm more than happy to take any day. However, I also don't mind an artist who sticks close to their roots as long as they do it well. Artists like Nada Surf, Counting Crows, and Foo Fighters have never strayed too far from their trademark sound but they do what they do so well and so consistently that I can't complain about it. Plus, even those artists have grown and branched out from time to time with great results.

There are a few artists who I feel have gotten an unfair shake from fans and critics and I'm going to look at the first one in this article. I'll do some more as I get time.

Weezer


Perhaps no other artist has garnered so much acclaim and so much backlash at the same time as Weezer. Ever since they burst onto the scene in the early 90's they've been one of the most controversial bands out there simply because of the direction they've gone. There's no denying that The Blue Album and Pinkerton are two of the best records of the 90's, if not of all-time. While those records are amazing they've also placed the band in the impossible corner of trying to live up to those songs and that period of their career. It's the problem that many artists face: a successful early career that they spend the rest of their lives having to match and be judged against. It's unfair but unfortunately it happens quite frequently.

Ever since 1996 Weezer has struggled to find a place that makes their fans happy and the amount of judgement and criticism they've encountered is not only unfair but downright childish in some cases. The simple fact is that Rivers Cuomo has shifted his songwriting into new areas and it's angered those hoping for a repeat of their first two albums. I really don't see where the complaining is coming from. Do fans really expect Rivers and Co. to never try new things or delve into new territory? Do they really want the same two albums recycled over and over again with no variation or unpredictability? Rivers hasn't always been the best lyricist but I applaud him for at least trying new things and sticking to his instinct. Sure, some of his writing is cheesy or cringe-worthy but it was that way even back on their debut. I expect a certain level of cheesiness and tongue-in-cheek humor when listening to Weezer. He's a husband and a father now with a happy life; I don't expect him to write the angry and love-torn songs he did 15 years ago. The emotion of Pinkerton isn't something you can force and trying that would be a disaster. I wouldn't mind the band going back to a heavier style but lyrically it would have to be different and I have no qualms with that.

It's not like the band's output since that time has been weak, despite what you may hear. The Green Album is pure power pop but it's upbeat and fun and reminded audiences that Weezer was still relevant and could write a song that you couldn't get out of your head. Maladroit, despite the hate it somehow receives, rocks like nobody's business and still remains one of my favorite records by the band. Albums like Hurly and Make Believe may have been hit-or-miss but they contain some great material while The Red Album found the band growing musically and lyrically. "The Angel and the One" is arguably the best song Rivers has ever penned and that entire album is full of interesting and amazing music. Once again though, it requires an open mind and for the listener to leave nostalgia behind, something many fans still can't seem to do.

Let me be clear that I DO understand where some of the naysayers are coming from. It's hard when something you love changes or reinvents itself and for those who grew up with the band's early work I can imagine how weird it must be to see them branching out. What's funny is that the band's sound really hasn't changed that much from the beginning. They're still rocking and musically they never stray too far from their trademark sound. It's just in a different package and coming from a different angle now. Music, like any form of art, is subjective and people are free to have their own tastes and opinions. I don't begrudge them that. I just feel they're missing out on some great music because they're stuck in the past or unwilling to let their prejudices go.

I'll admit that the band hasn't always hit their target (like Raditude, which is silly even by Weezer standards) but that's okay. That's part of growing as musicians and I feel that Weezer has done that. Sure, their first two albums are incredible and well-deserving of the praise they get. Still, that doesn't negate the work they've done since and all the work they have yet to do. Let the critics continue to complain; I'm too busy enjoying this band and I'm thankful they're still around and still giving us music. They've changed a bit over the years but you know something? I have too. It's called growth and maturity. I find it makes things better in the long run. I'm still enjoying Weezer and I'll be happy to tune in to whatever they do next. Sure, it may not be great but that's the risk that all true artists take and in the end that's what really matters.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Space Fact of the Week

10 Best Lyrics from Trouble Will Find Me

Underrated Record Club: Death Cab for Cutie - Codes and Keys