Underrated Record Club #8-Weezer's Maladroit

"If you hate this, I can't blame you" sings frontman Rivers Cuomo in the opener "American Gigolo". What he's referring to may be unclear but the album itself could very well be the topic of conversation. After reemerging after a five year hiatus with The Green Album in 2001, it didn't take the band long to release the follow-up a mere thirteen months later. Originally conceived as an experiment, the band posted demos and song ideas on their website and asked fans to give them feedback. How much this helped is debatable, especially since fans and Rivers had major disagreements over the creative aspects of the album. This didn't make it a totally failed experiment though: the album's title and cover were both chosen from fan-submitted ideas and the song "Slob" was added to the album by fan request, with Cuomo even stating that he would never have thought of adding the song to the record if fans hadn't suggested it. It wasn't all smooth but you have to give the band credit for trying something different and working with their fans on a more intimate level than most artists do.
Maladroit takes a lot of heat from fans and to this day I'm still puzzled as to why. It's loud, it's crisp, it's catchy, and it explores new territory with subtle heavy metal riffs sprinkled throughout the album. For fans who wanted Weezer to make a heavier and more experimental album then Maladroit should have satisfied them. Like I mentioned in an earlier article though, there are some jaded and picky fans out there who will simply never be satisfied with what the band does. I'm happy to say I'm not one of them and I love this record. Here's why:
"American Gigolo" is the perfect opener. Patrick Wilson's drums immediately hit you and the urgency rarely dies down during the album's brief 33 minute running time. "Dope Nose" and "Keep Fishin'" are the album's two singles and if they're not enough to suck you in then nothing will. The former is a quick adrenaline ride with punk riffs mixed in with a poppy chorus. The latter is the kind of power-pop we've all come to love from the group. I remember seeing the music video when it first came out (complete with The Muppets, no less!) and instantly being hooked by how catchy and fun the song was. Both are a great introduction to the album and stand as proof that there's plenty of worthy material to be found here.
What makes the album fun is the fact that it's very loose and somewhat scatterbrained. While the sound remains consistent, it's channeled in different ways. "Death and Destruction" slows things down a bit for and it's probably the closest the album comes to having a ballad on it. The lyrics are pretty predictable but I love the way the song swings from quiet to loud several times over. "Burndt Jam" is one of the tracks that most fans seem to love and it's laid-back groove is infectious and fun, giving the album a nice break halfway through. "Space Rock" finds Rivers singing in falsetto during the verses before reverting back to his normal voice during the chorus. It's probably a love-it-or-hate-it kind of track but I'm fond of it just because it's so different and unexpected. "Slave" is my favorite cut here and one of the best songs that Rivers has ever done. It's brilliant, catchy, loud, and incredibly infectious.
A few of the tracks blaze by so quickly that's is easy to miss them. "Fall Together" and "Possibilities" are two songs that drive so fast and so loud that they require a few listens to really grasp. "Slob" is a standard Weezer rocker and that's a good thing. Fans were wise to suggest it for the album and it could have been a successful single easily. "Love Explosion" is a blast (no pun intended), especially during the chorus, which sounds like an alternative version of "The Locomotion", complete with a blistering guitar solo. Brian Bell really lets them fly on this album and his guitar riffs give every song a heavy and dark edge that hits you full force. This was Scott Shriner's first album with the band as their new bassist and it's easy to see why he's stayed with the group ever since. His subtle bass lines really hold the songs together and keep the bottom end moving at a swift stride.
Like its title suggests, Maladroit is a bit clumsy and haphazard. It's all over the place and twists and turns so many times that it leaves you a bit dizzy. While I'm sure this is what bothers so many fans about the record, that's exactly what I love about it. Fans complain when Weezer releases pretty much anything these days and yet when given a chance to pick the songs and give their own input they still complain. I don't care what anyone says: this is one of the band's best albums and I find myself coming back to it over and over again. It's loud, it's fun, and it's classic Weezer from start to finish.
Comments
Post a Comment