What Is the Light?-My Journey to Find the True "Soft Bulletin"



If I had to make a list of my top five favorite albums of all time, The Soft Bulletin by The Flaming Lips would easily be in it. It's a masterpiece of epic proportions: daring, sprawling, heartfelt, and operatic. It's their finest hour and has been praised by fans and critics ever since it was released in 1999. It's a record that truly lives up to the hype and it officially cemented the band as one of the most original and brilliant groups out there. The fact that they hail from my home state of Oklahoma is something I take great pride in.

However, this isn't a history lesson or even an album review. They're a great band that everyone should look into and this album deserves a spot on the shelf of any serious music connoisseur. What I wanted to share instead is my strange journey to figure out what this album really is and why The Soft Bulletin that is widely available doesn't exactly give you the entire picture---or the entire album for that matter.

What I didn't realize at first is that the album has a different tracklist depending on where you are, with the U.S. and European/Australian versions differing. The recently released vinyl version mixes things up a bit more and the re-release of the album in 5.1 surround sound seems to be considered the preferred version of the album that the band originally intended to release. After reading about this I began to wonder: could I have been listening to a different album all this time? As it turns out, in many ways I was.

Please don't get me wrong: The Soft Bulletin is flawless no matter which version you have. A simple shuffling of the tracks can't diminish their greatness. Still, I'm an old-fashioned "listen to an album from start to finish" kind of guy and with a record as important and special to me as this one I wanted the version that the band intended to release. With three different CD versions and the vinyl edition, it can get a bit confusing. After purchasing the 5.1 CD/DVD version (which appears to be the final one) I'm happy to say that it's like listening to the album again for the first time, because in some ways I am.

The CD version that's widely available here in the U.S. features most of the tracks, with the exception of "Slow Motion", which is available on the U.K. and Australian version. However, they don't have "The Spiderbite Song", which the U.S. has. So essentially each country is missing a track that the other has. The typical U.S. CD looks like this:

1. Race for the Prize (remix)
2. A Spoonful Weighs a Ton
3. The Spark That Bled
4. The Spiderbite Song
5. Buggin' (remix)
6. What Is the Light?
7. The Observer
8. Waitin' for a Superman
9. Suddenly Everything Has Changed
10 The Gash
11. Feeling Yourself Disintegrate
12. Sleeping on the Roof
13. Race for the Prize
14. Waitin' for a Superman (remix)

One thing that's immediately apparent are the remixes. Back when the album was first released there was pressure from the record company for more commercial music, hence why several songs were remixed. That's okay for radio play but why they were left on the album, not to mention mixed in to take the place of the original tracks (like "Race for the Prize") makes no sense and really disrupts the flow of the album. Except for "Buggin'" (which sounds much different and is actually a great remix) the others are pointless and hardly distinguishable from the original tracks. The U.K. and Australian release shakes things up even more:

1. Race for the Prize
2. A Spoonful Weighs a Ton
3. The Spark That Bled
4. Slow Motion
5. What Is the Light?
6. The Observer
7. Waitin' for a Superman
8. Suddenly Everything Has Changed
9. The Gash
10. Feeling Yourself Disintegrate
11. Sleeping on the Roof
12. Race for the Prize (remix)
13. Waitin' for a Superman (remix)
14. Buggin' (remix)

This edition is a bit closer to what the band intended but it's not quite complete. It's nice to have the remixes left at the end but it's still not quite right. Similarly, the vinyl version is a bit different too but that's harder to come by so I won't delve into it here. As you can see, trying to figure out which version to get is frustrating and I never could tell which one was definitive. Again, the album is perfect no matter how it's laid out but as a diehard fan I wanted this special album to be the one the band originally wanted to release but couldn't back in 1999. Thankfully I found the answer in the 5.1 CD/DVD mix that was released back in 2006. I didn't pay much attention to this version until I read that this was the version the band prefers and that it included all 13 original songs and no remixes. Here's how this version, the final and approved one, is laid out:

1. Race for the Prize
2. A Spoonful Weighs a Ton
3. The Spark That Bled
4. Slow Motion
5. What Is the Light?
6. The Observer
7. Waitin' for a Superman
8. Suddenly Everything Has Changed
9. The Gash
10. Feeling Yourself Disintegrate
11. Sleeping on the Roof
12. The Spiderbite Song
13. Buggin'

It's like listening to a completely different album. The remixes are gone, "Slow Motion" is finally on this edition and the running order has been corrected. In fact, the original version of "Buggin'" is vastly different from the remix and it takes some getting used to because the remix is one of my favorites. Again, who knew that one of my favorite Flaming Lips songs was a remix? It's things like this that make me mad at record companies. They tend to muck up releases and hide listeners from what the artist originally created, meaning you can listen to something for years and never know that it's unfinished or different from the original. The new version is great and surprising.

At first it blew my mind: all these years I was listening to the album and yet it wasn't quite complete. Most people wouldn't care too much but when a record means this much to me I want it just the way the band intended for it to be and thankfully it's here, remastered, resequenced, and complete. I still have the original U.S. CD and the vinyl version because this is one of those albums where you can't own too many copies and it's fun to have the different versions. However, the 5.1 release is the one I'm listening to from now on. It's just beautiful.

No matter how you hear it, The Soft Bulletin is one of the best albums ever made. I recommend checking it out in any format, especially if you're not picky or can't find the 5.1 release. It's been a bizarre journey and finding the proper version of this record has been interesting to say the least. However, as I sit here listening to the album The Flaming Lips meant to release I feel at peace. It's still one of my favorites and now I'm getting to take the journey all over again. When the music is this good it makes it all worth it. Race for the prize indeed.

Comments

  1. I love how much you love music!


    Also, this entry is not about carrots, and I was a little disappointed that you didn't mention them at all.

    ;)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Believe it or not, I hate the Buggin' remix. The others are pointless, yes, but pretty good and don't diminish the impact of the songs. But Buggin' is a light hearted, playful song. Making it more poppy with a remix just makes it sound cheesy.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks for this write-up. I've been trying to figure this out for a while. The UK play order is the first one I heard, and I prefer it by far; the 2006 version looks just as good. Slow Motion is a great song, and is sorely missed on the US version. Spider and Buggin seem to come out of nowhere on the US version, while the UK play order works like one continuous suite for me.

    I'm actually new to the band, and got this album by accident (it was left on a used iPod I bought). Took me a few listens to get in to it, but now it's one of my all-time favorite CDs, and the Lips are suddenly my favorite band, so I'm listening through their entire back catalog. Love it! The suite-like play order of the UK version is one big reason why I stuck with the album.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Space Fact of the Week

10 Best Lyrics from Trouble Will Find Me

Underrated Record Club: Death Cab for Cutie - Codes and Keys