Underrated Record Club #4-Radiohead's Amnesiac

I know what you're thinking: how can anything of Radiohead's be underrated? After all, they're one of the most critically acclaimed groups in history and have had a huge following for over 15 years. People love this band and I'm certainly one of them. I think they're brilliant and they're one of my favorite bands. I also agree that the majority of their output has been stellar and worthy of the praise it gets. However, even a great band has some works that tend to fall between the cracks and get overlooked. This is where Amnesiac, the band's fifth album, comes in. I've always liked this record and I think most fans do as well; it just has a lot to live up to, especially considering that it followed masterpieces like The Bends, OK Computer, and Kid A.
To be fair, the band's debut album Pablo Honey is their most maligned, mostly because it sounds so different and far removed from the band that Radiohead would eventually morph into. It's a decent record with some enjoyable songs but, in my humble opinion, it pales in comparison to everything the band has done since. Most fans and critics (and even the band members themselves) seem to agree on that so I'm only focusing on their work from The Bends on up.
Most of the songs on Amnesiac were written and recorded at the same time as those on Kid A, causing the band to decide to release two separate albums. Kid A came out in 2000 while Amnesiac appeared the following year. Both albums were major departures for the band and definitely left a lot of people scratching their heads. Kid A has always been the more popular of the two and I have to admit that it's the superior album. That being said, Amnesiac isn't just an album of leftovers or second-rate tracks but rather a companion piece that takes the questions and uncertainty of the first record and builds upon them. It's a more challenging and wild record but no less exciting and worthwhile for those with the patience to delve into it.
The album opens with "Packt Like Sardines in a Crushd Tin Box". Just the title and spelling alone let you know that this will be another musical detour. It's opening rhythms and synthetic sound seem to pick up right where Kid A left off, where frontman Thom Yorke wastes no time in singing, "Get off my case, get off my case". "Pyramid Song" is a highlight on the album, which its gentle piano that slowly builds as each band member comes in to eventually give the song a more traditional structure and shape. It also features some of the best lyrics and imagery on the album: "I jumped in the river and what did I see?/Black-eyed angels swam withe me/A moon full of stars and astral cars/And all the figures I used to see/All my lovers were there with me/All my past and futures/And we all went to heaven in a little rowboat/There was nothing to fear, nothing to doubt".
The album continues to explore electronic sounds and beats with "Pulk/Pull Revolving Doors". The sounds and textures the band uses here are real ear candy and Yorke's robotic voice floats effortlessly over the top of it. Audiophiles will have a lot of fun trying to pick apart the various sounds going on and the entire album is full of these wonderful moments. In terms of sounds and instrumentation this album may be Radiohead's most diverse and layered to date. "I Might Be Wrong" and "Knives Out" are two of the most popular cuts from the album. They have a bit more of a traditional sound but there are also enough small instrumental and electronic touches thrown in that they never become too predictable or familiar. The drums and guitar work are great to hear, especially because they really get so little time here and are often relegated to the background on a majority of the songs. "You and Whose Army?" features a simple arrangement at first but Yorke's distinctive voice manages to keep your attention and pull the song along in a chilling fashion until the rest of the band comes in and flushes it out into a beautiful finale.
"Morning Bell/Amnesiac" takes the song "Morning Bell" from Kid A and adds a new arrangement to it, giving us two completely different takes on the song depending on which album you're listening to. I'm still undecided about which version I like better but it's neat to see it make another appearance here. "Hunting Bears" is a brief two minute instrumental that's not terribly memorable but isn't bad either. I just see it as another sign of the band willing to explore and do the unexpected, which is why so many of us love them in the first place.
The song "Like Spinning Plates" is interesting because, to be perfectly honest, I really can't find the right words to describe it. I love it and the "swooshing" background to it but I'm at a loss as how to translate that into words so just listen to it and decide for yourself. "Dollars & Cents" is another track that sounds more familiar while the closer "Life in a Glass House" is amazing. It features a jazz arrangement and it still remains one of my favorites on the record. It's use of horns and jazz influences is impressive and really ends the album in style. That's what this era of Radiohead did best: incorporating jazz, electronic music, classical elements, and subtle rock into one massive package. They seem like an unlikely pairing but this album, as well as it's predecessor, are a great example of how anything is possible in the right hands and under the right circumstances.
A lot of people seem to think this album is just leftovers from Kid A when really it couldn't be further from the truth. These songs are definitely more wild and some of them lack the precise structure that so many of Kid A's tracks had. However, that in no way makes them inferior or throwaways. It's a challenging listen and if you're new to the band then this is certainly not the best place to start. It's a wild ride and one that I enjoy taking time and time again. When compared to most of their other records it may not place near the top but it's still a wonderful and important piece of their discography that deserves more credit and appreciation than it gets. It's not the kind of album that will suck in new listeners or get commercial airplay but Radiohead has never cared about that anyway. They make music for the sake of art and Amnesiac is a prime example of that. It's messy and confusing and dissonant at times but the more you look into it the more beauty and potential shine through. Be sure to give this one a shot and make up your own mind. It's worth it.
Comments
Post a Comment