Underrated Record Club #1- R.E.M.'s Around the Sun

Every artist seems to have it: that one album that people consider a failure, a mistake, an embarrassment, or a good idea that turned into a bad one. The whole goal of this series is to examine some of those albums from my favorite artists and point out that, while they may not be the best, they're still worthwhile albums and perhaps even great ones that simply never got their chance to shine.
The members of R.E.M. are certainly no strangers to this. For nearly 30 years this band from Athens, Georgia has created some of the most memorable and exciting music of our time. Songs like "Losing My Religion", "Everybody Hurts", "The One I Love", and "Orange Crush" are easily recognizable to any listener and they've helped make the band one of the biggest and most popular in the world, complete with their introduction into the Rock n' Roll Hall of Fame in 2007. They're never slowed down and still continue to make great music despite drummer Bill Berry leaving the band in 1997. They've continued as a three-piece and managed to reinvent themselves time and time again.
As with any long-running artist, they have a big fan base that loves to discuss their work. Some albums like Murmer, Life's Rich Pageant, and Automatic for the People will always be considered classics while others like Monster and Up seem to divide fans and critics alike. However, one album that seems to garner universal distain is 2004's Around the Sun. Upon its release it was met with lukewarm reviews and was the band's first album since 1988 to fail to make the Top Ten in the U.S.. Some of the complaints about this album are valid but upon closer inspection I believe there's also a lot to offer here as well.
Upon my first listen I had to agree with fans and critics: it just wasn't very good at all. It sounded flat, dull, and lifeless with uninteresting songs and boring arrangements. However, I also knew that most R.E.M. albums are growers and take several listens to fully appreciate, so I kept with it and soon discovered myself enjoying a majority of the record. The opener "Leaving New York" was the lead single and when I first heard it in 2004 I was underwhelmed; it just felt bland to me and it wasn't until picking this album up last year and really listening to it that I came to discover what a beautiful song it really is. For anyone who's ever visited the city or had to leave a place that they love then the song will definitely resonate with you in some way. Peter Buck's jangly guitar works its magic here while bassist Mike Mills offers up his usual top-notch backing vocals and singer Michael Stipe's voice is solid, something that has never changed over the band's career. He sounds just as good now, if not better, than he did 20 years ago.
Two songs that immediately caught my attention are "Electron Blue" and "I Wanted to Be Wrong". "Electron Blue" is one of my favorite R.E.M. songs and rides a wave of electronic sounds that are reminiscent of some of their late 90's work. It's a great song and a staple of the album. "I Wanted to Be Wrong" is an acoustic-themed number that features more of Stipe's amazing vocals and a gentle melody and passionate lyrics:
You know where I come from
you know what I feel
You're Yul Brenner Westworld
reporting from the field.
I threw it into reverse,
made a motion to repeal.
You kicked my legs from under me,
and tried to take the wheel.
I told you I wanted to be wrong,
but everyone is humming a song
that I don't understand.
It definitely features an anti-war theme but the lyrics are also vague enough that they can apply to almost any situation. Don't miss this one because it gets better with every listen.
The album features some other solid numbers as well. "Make It All Okay", "The Ascent of Man", and "Final Straw" are all decent numbers that I've grown to love more and more over time. "Aftermath" is another high point that actually serves as a fitting metaphor for the entire record: a great song that at first sounds like the kind of pop song that the band can write in their sleep. The melody is upbeat and playful but it wasn't until I really listened to the lyrics that I realized what a devastating piece of work it is:
And you close your eyes.
He's not coming back.
So you work it out, overfeed the cat.
And the plants are dry and they need to drink.
So you do your best and you flood the sink.
Sit down in the kitchen and cry.
Now you've worked it out
And you see it all
And you've worked it out
It ends on a more optimistic note but the themes of being left behind and betrayed seem to a recurring stream running through the album and lend toward its melancholy atmosphere. "Aftermath" is a slice of classic R.E.M. and it's catchy enough to draw in anyone willing to give it a shot.
"The Outsiders" is decent and features a rap by Q-Tip at the end of it which actually works better than it sounds. It's not nearly as cheesy as "Radio Song" was on Out of Time while "The Worst Joke Ever" and the album's title track are serviceable enough. They probably won't blow you away but they're enjoyable in their own right. "Boy in the Well" is another song that's not amazing but not bad either and manages to at least keep the record moving.
That's not to say that every song comes close. "Wanderlust" starts out with a haunting keyboard part before suddenly swerving into a bouncy pop melody that sounds a bit too silly. It's alright but seems like it could have been so much more. However, my least-favorite track has to be "High Speed Train", a song title that implies kinetic motion but instead moves at a snail's pace and really doesn't go anywhere during it's five minute duration.
Around the Sun will never be hailed as a classic the way many of their previous albums have. Its soft acoustic sounds and slow pacing don't work as well as they did on albums like Automatic for the People and Reveal, causing the whole album to feel a bit unfocused and unsure of itself. I can understand why many fans were disappointed and understandably so; even the band members themselves seem to wish they had done things differently according to some interviews. The album definitely could have been better but they should be proud of what they did get right, which is really quite a bit in my opinion.
That being said, I do believe it's better than most give it credit for and I actually find myself enjoying it quite a bit whenever I listen to it. It has a few standouts and some great lyrics that are definitely applicable to my life at the moment and the anger and hurt of these songs speaks to me. It's not an album you'll love on your first or even fourth listen but eventually, when taken for what it is, you may find yourself enjoying another trip around the sun. I know I have.
Comments
Post a Comment